All Old Fashioned Candy

Filter By

Sort By:

  • Product
  • Qty in Cart
  • Quantity
  • Price
  • Subtotal
  • Bonomo Turkish Taffy Vanilla, 24 creamy light-colored thin taffy bars.

    Bonomo Turkish Taffy Vanilla 24 Piece

    $31.25
    Bonomo Turkish Taffy Vanilla 24 Piece Bonomo Turkish Taffy Vanilla 24 Piece. Smack it, crack it, and enjoy this creamy vanilla taffy nostalgic candy. A perfect addition to your next retro candy bar. Each pack contains 24 Bonomo Turkish Taffy bars. Don't...
  • Gilliam Old Fashioned Birthday Cake hard candy sticks, 80 individually wrapped rainbow-striped retro 5-inch sticks.

    Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Birthday Cake 80 Sticks

    $26.85
    Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Birthday Cake 80 SticksGilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Birthday Cake 80 sticks. Retro candy sticks like you would find at an old fashioned penny candy store. Each beautifully rainbow-striped hard candy stick is...
  • Gilliam Old Fashioned Tangerine hard candy sticks, 80 orange & white striped individually wrapped sticks in a box.

    Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Tangerine 80 Sticks

    $33.95
    Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Tangerine 80 Sticks Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Tangerine, 80 sticks, offers a taste of retro nostalgia. Enjoy 80 orange and white striped candy sticks that bring back memories of old-fashioned penny candy stores...
  • Eight pack Iconic Retro Sours Mango hard candies. Bright yellow-orange tropical sour mango candy in retro-themed tins. Iconic Retro Sours Mango 8-pack. Vibrant yellow hard candies, tangy tropical mango sour flavor in 8 tins.

    Iconic Retro Sours Mango 8 pack

    $29.95
    Iconic Retro Sours Mango 8 Pack Take your taste buds on a tropical trip with Iconic Retro Sours – Mango! These bold, tangy hard candies pack a punch of sweet mango flavor balanced by a mouthwatering sour twist. Inspired by the classic sour candies...
  • 12 count Milk Duds, 5oz classic brown boxes. Chewy milk chocolate and caramel candy by Hershey.
    Out of Stock
    Out of Stock

    Milk Duds 5 oz Box 12 Pack

    $31.25
    Milk Duds 5oz Box 12 Pack.  For a delicious bite of chocolate and chewy caramel, shop our wide selection of Milk Duds. At Candy Nation, we have the classic round confection that will last through closing credits! Milk Duds are made of 'toffee-like'...
  • Chick O Stick 36-piece box, crunchy peanut candy with toasted coconut sprinkles, old fashioned, retro. Box of 36 Chick O Stick crunchy peanut candies, tan, sprinkled with white toasted coconut.

    Chick O Stick 36 Piece

    $16.95
    Chick O Stick 36 Piece Chick O Stick 36 Piece. The old Chicken Bones candy now has a new name, but the recipe remains the same. These crunchy peanut candies are sprinkled with toasted coconut and come in a 36-count box. Made in the USA. Old Fashioned...
  • 80 individually wrapped colorful Gilliam old fashioned bubble gum hard candy sticks, 5-inch.

    Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Bubble Gum 80 Sticks

    $26.85
    Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Bubble Gum 80 sticksGilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Bubble Gum is a delightful treat that will take you back in time. This retro candy is reminiscent of the colorful and delicious candy sticks you would find at an...
  • Hubba Bubba Bubble Tape Original bubble gum, 6 pink packs, 6 feet each. Bubble Tape Original pink bubble gum 6-pack, 6 feet per roll.

    Hubba Bubba Bubble Tape Original 6 Pack

    $15.95
    Bubble Tape Original 6 Pack Bubble Tape Original 6 Pack Enjoy 6 FEET of Awesome Original Bubble Tape bubble gum in each container. Each order contains 6 Packs of Awesome Original flavor Bubble Tape. Perfect for parties and events. Order now from Candy...
  • 18 Zagnut candy bars, red packaging, crispy peanut butter center, toasted coconut coating. Hershey retro candy. 18 Zag Nut candy bars, crispy peanut butter center, toasted white coconut flakes, retro red packaging.

    Zag Nut Candy Bar 18 piece

    $37.65
    Zag Nut Candy Bars ZAGNUT Bars are a retro candy classic that deliver a uniquely crave-worthy combo! Each bar starts with a crispy, crunchy peanut butter center, then gets a generous coating of sweet, toasted coconut flakes for a one-of-a-kind treat...
  • 240 sour satellite wafer flying saucer candies, colorful thin wafers, and tangy powder, a retro novelty treat.

    Sour Satellite Wafer Flying Saucer Candy 240 Piece

    $23.65
    Sour Satellite Wafer Flying Saucer Candy 240 PieceSour Satellite Wafer Flying Saucer Candy 240 Piece. Satellite wafers, also known as \flying saucers,\ are thin wafer candy that surrounds a sour powder. When this candy was first introduced, outer space...
  • 24 black grape Wack-O Wax Mustache Candy, fun old-fashioned retro novelty wax mustaches for playing, chewing. 24 black grape-flavored Wack-O Wax Mustache Candy, classic novelty wax treat.

    Wack-O Wax Mustache Candy 24 Piece

    $42.35
    Wack-O Wax Mustache Candy 24 PieceWack-O Wax Mustache Candy 24 Piece Grape-flavored Wack-O-Wax mustaches are the all-time favorite “Play Now, Chew Later” wax treat. These classic mustache candies are perfect for anyone looking to add some fun to their...
  • Red wax lips, 24 count, classic old-fashioned novelty candy, fun, goofy retro treat. Wax Lips, 24 red novelty candy per pack, old-fashioned silly classic for Valentine's Day fun.

    Wax Lips

    $43.95
    Wax LipsWax Lips are a fun and silly novelty candy that make the perfect old-fashioned Valentine's present. These wack-o wax lips are sure to bring a smile to anyone's face and are great for the whole family to enjoy. With 24 wax lips per pack, you'll...
  • Gilliam Old Fashioned Passion Fruit hard candy sticks, 80 beautifully striped, individually wrapped, 5 inch long sticks.

    Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Passion Fruit 80 Sticks

    $32.25
    Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Passion Fruit 80 Sticks Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Passion Fruit 80 sticks. Retro candy sticks like you would find at an old fashioned penny candy store. Each beautifully striped hard candy stick is individually...
  • Goetze's Caramel Creams Apple candy, chewy brown caramel ring, white cream center, 40 pieces per pound. Goetze's Caramel Creams Apple candy, multiple chewy tan caramel rings, white cream centers. Iconic Bull's-Eye apple caramel candy.

    Goetze's Caramel Creams Apple

    $9.65
    Goetze's Caramel Creams Apple Goetze's Caramel Apple Caramel Creams are a limited-edition take on the iconic, century-old "Bull's-Eye" candy. Each piece features a ring of Goetze’s signature, chewy caramel infused with the tangy flavor of a Granny...
  • Jujyfruits 12-pack theater boxes, 60 chewy fruity pieces per box, classic red, orange, yellow, green, black candies. Jujyfruits Theater Box, 12 pack. Multi-colored chewy fruit candy in red, orange, yellow, green, black.

    Jujyfruits Theater Box 12 Pack

    $26.85
    Jujyfruits Theater Box 12 Pack Jujyfruits Theater Box 12 Pack.  Since the 1920s, candy lovers have been enjoying this chewy fruity candy.  This retro candy classic still comes in all your favorite flavors:  Red Raspberry, Orange,...
  • Total: items /

Adding your products to cart

View Cart Continue Shopping

All Old Fashioned Candy transports you to simpler, sweeter days, offering classic confections that evoke nostalgia and charm. Perfect for themed parties, vintage events, or simply reliving cherished childhood memories, these candies are beloved for their timeless flavors and traditional appeal. They're ideal for creating unique candy buffets, thoughtful retro party favors, or sharing stories across generations. Discover the enduring joy of Licorice Allsorts, with their distinctive shapes and chewy textures, or the satisfying snap and long-lasting flavor of classic Rock Candy sticks. Explore our collection and rediscover the sweet tastes of yesteryear!