- Product
- Qty in Cart
- Quantity
- Price
- Subtotal
-
Out of StockOut of StockOld Fashioned Christmas Candy - All Filled
$9.65Old Fashioned Christmas Candy - All Filled Old Fashioned Christmas Candy - All Filled are classic unwrapped hard candies with chocolatey centers—smooth, rich fillings that offer a surprising contrast... -
Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Orange 80 Sticks
$27.95Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Orange 80 Sticks Get nostalgic with Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Orange. Shop now for these 5-inch retro candy sticks perfect for candy lovers. Gilliam Stick... -
Pop Rocks Cherry 24 Pack
$24.95Pop Rocks Cherry 24 Pack Pop Rocks Cherry 24 Pack. These Cherry Pop Rocks come in the original packaging from the 1970's. Great for your Retro Candy display. Fun Fact: Pop Rocks were introduced in... -
Junior Mints Theater Box 12 Piece
$26.85Junior Mints Theater Box 12 Piece Junior Mints Theater Box 12 Piece - Rich dark chocolate combined with the cool, fresh flavor of peppermint. First introduced in 1949, Junior Mints are the perfect... -
Goetze's Caramel Creams Vanilla 100 piece tub
$20.45Goetze's Caramel Creams Vanilla 100 piece tubGoetze's Caramel Creams Vanilla 100 piece tub This caramel candy is also known as bullseye candy. It has a creamy center with a chewy caramel outside... -
Teaberry Gum
$13.95Teaberry GumTeaberry Gum is a sweet and minty old-time gum made from the original recipe. Each pack contains 5 sticks of gum, and there are 20 packs in a box. This nostalgic candy brings back the... -
Bazooka Throwback Wallet Original 12 Pack
$12.85Bazooka Throwback Wallet Original 12 PackBazooka Throwback Original Wallet 12 Pack Welcome back, Bazooka Joe! Inspired by the original packaging and comic strips, the Throwback Wallet includes the... -
Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Root Beer 80 Sticks
$27.95Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Root Beer 80 Sticks Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Root Beer 80 sticks. Retro candy sticks like you would find at an old fashioned penny candy store. Each... -
Out of StockOut of StockOld Fashioned Peppermint Sticks
$15.05Old Fashioned Peppermint SticksOld Fashioned Peppermint Sticks bring back the nostalgic joy of Christmas with their festive red and white stripes. These delicious candies have a thin crispy shell... -
Out of StockOut of StockRed Shoestring Licorice Laces 2 Pounds Kervan
$8.55Red Shoestring Licorice Laces 2 Pounds Kervan Deliciously sweet and tangy, these Red Shoestring Licorice Laces by Kervan are sure to delight your taste buds. Made with premium ingredients, this... -
Laffy Taffy Assorted 145 Piece
$24.75Laffy Taffy Assorted 145 Piece Laffy Taffy Assorted 145 Piece flavors include Cherry, Sour Apple, Banana, and Strawberry. Each piece is individually wrapped. 145 pieces of Assorted Laffy Taffy per... -
Iconic Retro Sours Tangerine 8 pack
$29.95Iconic Retro Sours Tangerine 8 Pack Get ready for a citrus blast from the past with Iconic Retro Sours – Tangerine! These bold, zesty hard candies combine the bright, juicy flavor of tangerine with a... -
Out of StockOut of StockLeman's Mint Sugar Free Candy
$15.95Leman's Mint Sugar Free Candy Leman's Mint Sugar Free Candy is the perfect treat for all of the old-fashioned candy lovers out there. This classic individually wrapped "church mint" is now available... -
Nik L Nip Wax Bottles 12 Pack
$31.25Nik L Nip Wax Bottles 12 PackNik L Nip Wax Bottles 12 Pack is a retro candy that is sure to bring back memories. These wax bottle shapes are filled with a delicious fruit flavor liquid that will... -
Sugar Daddy JR 48 Piece
$14.95Sugar Daddy JR 48 Piece LollipopsSugar Daddy JR 48 Pack. Delicious milk caramel sucker. Individually wrapped, 40 Sugar Daddy Jr pops per box.Get your Sugar Daddy JR 48 Piece Lollipops from Candy...
All Old Fashioned Candy transports you to simpler, sweeter days, offering classic confections that evoke nostalgia and charm. Perfect for themed parties, vintage events, or simply reliving cherished childhood memories, these candies are beloved for their timeless flavors and traditional appeal. They're ideal for creating unique candy buffets, thoughtful retro party favors, or sharing stories across generations. Discover the enduring joy of Licorice Allsorts, with their distinctive shapes and chewy textures, or the satisfying snap and long-lasting flavor of classic Rock Candy sticks. Explore our collection and rediscover the sweet tastes of yesteryear!