All Old Fashioned Candy

Filter By

Sort By:

  • Product
  • Qty in Cart
  • Quantity
  • Price
  • Subtotal
  • Red shoestring licorice laces, 2 pounds, approx 100 2.5-foot long strings, retro candy.

    Red Shoestring Licorice Laces 2 Pounds

    $15.95
    Red Shoestring Licorice Laces 2 Pounds Take a walk down memory lane with these Red Shoestring Licorice Laces. Tie them, braid them, or lasso these sweet treats to have as much fun playing with them as you do eating them. These delightful treats are the...
  • Necco Wafers, 24 rolls. Assorted lemon, lime, orange, clove, cinnamon, wintergreen, licorice, chocolate flavored candy wafers. Necco Wafers, 24-count box of 2.02 oz rolls. Assorted colorful lemon, lime, orange, clove, cinnamon, wintergreen, licorice, chocolate.

    Necco Wafers

    $39.55
    Necco Wafers Necco Wafers – The Original Candy Wafer is back and ready to delight candy lovers everywhere! First introduced in 1847, Necco Wafers have become a beloved nostalgic treat. Now made by Spangler Candy Company, this assortment of flavors...
  • Charleston Chew Variety Pack, 12 individually wrapped candy bars, chocolate, vanilla, strawberry flavors.

    Charleston Chew Variety Pack 12 Piece

    $23.65
    Charleston Chew Variety Pack 12 PieceThe Charleston Chew Variety Pack 12 Piece is a delicious assortment of candy bars that are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth. This pack includes three popular flavors: chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry. Each bar is...
  • Assorted old fashioned Christmas hard candies, colorful unwrapped shapes, peppermints, fruit, dark chocolate-filled. Old fashioned Christmas hard candy mix, various bright colors & shapes. Quality Candy Co. retro filled candy with dark chocolatey centers.
    Out of Stock
    Out of Stock

    Old Fashioned Christmas Candy Filled and Hard Mix

    $8.55
    Old Fashioned Christmas Candy Filled and Hard Mix A nostalgic mix of Filled and Hard Christmas candy. Classic unwrapped hard candies in various colors, shapes, and flavors await to transport you back to cherished holiday memories. Among the assortment,...
  • Pile of Boyer Smoothie Cups Unwrapped, light brown butterscotch & peanut butter old-fashioned candy, approx 30 per pound. Group of 30 unwrapped Boyer Smoothie Cups, golden-brown peanut butter and butterscotch candies.

    Boyer Smoothie Cups Unwrapped

    $13.95
    Boyer Smoothie Cups UnwrappedBoyer Smoothie Cups Unwrapped are a delightful treat that combines the creaminess of peanut butter with the rich flavor of butterscotch. Made by Boyer, a company with a long history of crafting delicious candies, these...
  • Mini Goetze's Cow Tales candy bag, 4oz. Classic caramel cream flavor, individually wrapped mini 2.5-inch treats.

    Mini Cow Tales Candy 4oz Bag

    $2.75
    Mini Cow Tales Candy 4oz BagMini Cow Tales Candy 4oz Bag is a classic Goetze's caramel cream flavor in a mini wrapped treat! This fabulous candy features a soft cream center covered in caramel. Each piece is about 2.5 inches in length, and each bag...
  • Gilliam yellow butterscotch old fashioned hard candy, 80 individually wrapped retro sticks.

    Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Butterscotch 80 Sticks

    $32.25
    Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Butterscotch 80 Sticks Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Butterscotch is a must-have for lovers of retro candy and those looking to indulge their sweet tooth. The yellow, butterscotch flavor is a crowd-pleaser that will...
  • 1980s Retro Candy Box, 2lb, over 50 pieces. Assorted colorful candies: Ring Pop, Starburst, Nerds, Skittles, Pixy Sticks.

    Made in the 1980's Retro Candy Box

    $26.85
    Made in the 1980's Retro Candy Box Travel back to the future with Candy Nation.  Pop a mix tape in your boombox and enjoy some retro candy from the 1980's.  This treat box contains 2lb of candies that were popular in the 1980's...
  • Mike and Ike Original 24 pack, rainbow chewy candy, 0.78oz individual boxes.

    Mike and Ike Original 24 Pack

    $7.95
    Mike and Ike Original 24 PackGet your taste of nostalgia with this Rainbow candy. Order now for a sweet treat!The Mike and Ike Original 24 Pack is the perfect choice for candy lovers who want a delicious and chewy treat. The pack includes 24 0.78oz boxes...
  • Iconic red Pop Rocks Strawberry candy, 24 individual packs.

    Pop Rocks Strawberry 24 Pack

    $24.95
    Pop Rocks Strawberry 24 Pack Pop Rocks Strawberry 24 Pack. Taste the Explosion with Strawberry Pop Rocks! Fun Fact: Pop Rocks were introduced in the 1970’s, selling 500 million packages in only 18 months! They became the “the hottest selling...
  • 80 Gilliam Old Fashioned Cinnamon stick candy, individually wrapped, 5-inch red & white striped hard candy. 80 Gilliam Old Fashioned Cinnamon hard candy sticks, red and white striped, individually wrapped, 5 inches long.

    Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Cinnamon 80 Sticks

    $32.25
    Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Cinnamon 80 Sticks The Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Cinnamon is reminiscent of the retro candy sticks found at old-fashioned penny candy stores. Individually wrapped, each beautifully striped hard candy stick...
  • 36 large brown 2.25oz Tootsie Roll bars, individually wrapped chewy retro candy. Tootsie Roll 36-piece box, large 2.25oz chewy brown candy bars, classic retro gluten-free concession stand treat.

    Tootsie Roll 36 Piece

    $77.65
    Tootsie Roll 36 PieceTootsie Roll 36 Piece. Simply large versions of the bite-sized candy we have grown to love. Each bar is 2.25oz. 36 Tootsie Rolls per box.Old Fashioned CandyRetro CandyChewy CandyConcession Stand CandyTootsie Roll
  • 36 Indian Salted Pumpkin Seeds packs, bright red mini bags, old fashioned retro salty snack. 36 Indian Salted Pumpkin Seeds, bright red retro mini bags, classic salty crunch, old fashioned candy.
    Out of Stock
    Out of Stock

    Indian Salted Pumpkin Seeds 36 Pack

    $13.95
    Indian Salted Pumpkin Seeds 36 PackIndian Salted Pumpkin Seeds 36 Pack. Crunch into classic Indian Brand Pumpkin Seeds. This old fashioned snack is just as you remember it: oh-so salty with a superior crunch factor. These Indian Pumpkin Seeds are sold in...
  • Old Fashioned Christmas hard candies, unwrapped, with chocolate-filled centers. Classic retro candy in festive colors. Old Fashioned Christmas unwrapped hard candies, rich chocolatey centers, assorted festive colors.
    Out of Stock
    Out of Stock

    Old Fashioned Christmas Candy - All Filled

    $9.65
    Old Fashioned Christmas Candy - All Filled Old Fashioned Christmas Candy - All Filled are classic unwrapped hard candies with chocolatey centers—smooth, rich fillings that offer a surprising contrast to the hard candy shell. These filled treats...
  • 48 fun size golden brown Chick O Stick crispy peanut butter candy with toasted coconut. 48 fun size crispy, light brown Chick O Stick peanut butter candies with toasted coconut. Classic American made.

    Chick O Stick Fun Size 48 Piece

    $9.65
    Chick O Stick Fun Size 48 Piece Chick O Stick Fun Size 48 Piece is a blast from the past that will transport you back to your childhood. These crispy peanut butter treats, sprinkled with toasted coconut, will make you fall in love with the classic taste...
  • Total: items /

Adding your products to cart

View Cart Continue Shopping

All Old Fashioned Candy transports you to simpler, sweeter days, offering classic confections that evoke nostalgia and charm. Perfect for themed parties, vintage events, or simply reliving cherished childhood memories, these candies are beloved for their timeless flavors and traditional appeal. They're ideal for creating unique candy buffets, thoughtful retro party favors, or sharing stories across generations. Discover the enduring joy of Licorice Allsorts, with their distinctive shapes and chewy textures, or the satisfying snap and long-lasting flavor of classic Rock Candy sticks. Explore our collection and rediscover the sweet tastes of yesteryear!