All Old Fashioned Candy

Old Fashioned Peppermint SticksOld Fashioned Peppermint Sticks bring back the nostalgic joy of Christmas with their festive red and white stripes. These delicious candies have a thin crispy shell that gives way to a creamy mint filling. Each peppermint...

Mini Cow Tales Candy 4oz BagMini Cow Tales Candy 4oz Bag is a classic Goetze's caramel cream flavor in a mini wrapped treat! This fabulous candy features a soft cream center covered in caramel. Each piece is about 2.5 inches in length, and each bag...

Leman's Mint Sugar Free CandyLeman's Mint Sugar Free Candy is the perfect treat for all of the old-fashioned candy lovers out there. This classic individually wrapped \church mint\ is now available in a sugar-free version, making it a guilt-free...

Vanilla Charleston Chews Changemaker 36 PieceVanilla Charleston Chews Changemaker 36 Piece is a delicious treat that combines vanilla nougat with a chocolatey coating. Named after the popular 1920's dance, the Charleston, this candy bar is perfect for...

Mallo Cups UnwrappedMallo Cups Unwrapped are a delicious and nostalgic treat brought to you by Boyer Candies. These old-fashioned marshmallow candies are made with shredded coconut mixed in sweet chocolate and filled with a whipped marshmallow center...

Teaberry GumTeaberry Gum is a sweet and minty old-time gum made from the original recipe. Each pack contains 5 sticks of gum, and there are 20 packs in a box. This nostalgic candy brings back the flavors of the past and is perfect for anyone who loves...

Red and White Striped Mint StrawsRed and White Striped Mint Straws are a classic Christmas candy that will add a festive touch to any occasion. Made in Canada by Cavalier Candies, these peppermint-flavored straws are a nostalgic treat that are sure to...

Lemonheads 24 PackLemonheads 24 Pack. These mini Lemonheads are nice and sour and easily transportable in this cute yellow box! Great changemaker candies. Each display box contains 24 packs of Lemonheads candy, packs are .8oz.Mini CandyLemon CandyYellow...

Claey's Hard Candy - AniseAre you an old-time candy lover? Then these nostalgic Anise flavored hard candies are perfect for you! The wonderful licorice herb candy bursts with flavor in just a single square. Consider these for a nostalgic Christmas candy...

Lemon Fruit Slices UnwrappedLemon Fruit Slices Unwrapped are sweet and tangy, bursting with flavor and color. These delightful jelly candies have an amazing resemblance to real lemon slices, coated with sugar for a satisfying snack. They are perfect for...

McCraw's Giant Flat Taffy 24 Piece The delicious old-fashioned retro taffy you have grown to love, in a fun flat assortment. Slip one in your backpack for an afternoon snack, or enjoy anytime for a creamy nostalgic treat.  Each piece is individually...

Beemans Gum With its distinctive herbal and wintergreen flavor, boasts a unique lineage dating back to 1890. It was invented by Ohio physician Dr. Edward E. Beeman, who originally marketed it as a digestive aid, claiming it contained pepsin. While pepsin...

Charleston Chew Variety Pack 12 PieceThe Charleston Chew Variety Pack 12 Piece is a delicious assortment of candy bars that are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth. This pack includes three popular flavors: chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry. Each bar is...

Clove Chewing Gum 20 PackClove Chewing Gum 20 Pack - Once again, this iconic clove-flavored gum is available for your enjoyment. 5 sticks per pack, 20 packs per box. Enjoy the nostalgic flavor with huge discounts on old-fashioned clove candy. Order now...

Black Jack Chewing Gum 20 PacksBlack Jack Chewing Gum 20 Pack Once again, this anise-flavored iconic gum is back! Stock up and enjoy it while it's available. 5 sticks per pack, 20 packs of Black Jack Chewing Gum per box.Chewing GumRetro CandyOld...