All Old Fashioned Candy

Filter By

Sort By:

  • Product
  • Qty in Cart
  • Quantity
  • Price
  • Subtotal
  • Atkinson Chick-O-Stick Bites, crispy 1-inch peanut butter candy with toasted coconut. 75 pieces per pound. Classic golden brown Chick O Stick Bites, crispy peanut butter candy with toasted coconut. About 75 one-inch pieces per pound.

    Chick O Stick

    $7.65
    Chick O Stick Chick-O-Stick is the perfect nostalgic treat that takes you back to your childhood! Formerly known as "Chicken Bones" candy, this classic favorite has remained unchanged in both recipe and manufacturing since the 1940s. Indulge in the...
  • Jelly Belly Licorice Bridge Mix, black licorice jelly beans, red and black buttons, nonpareil buttons, licorice pastels. Jelly Belly Licorice Bridge Mix, black, red, and nonpareil licorice jelly beans, pastels, buttons. 1lb, 250 pieces.
    Out of Stock
    Out of Stock

    Jelly Belly Licorice Bridge Mix

    $13.95
    Jelly Belly Licorice Bridge MixLooking for an assortment of black licorice candies to satisfy your sweet tooth? Look no further than Jelly Belly Licorice Bridge Mix! This delightful mix includes Black Licorice Jelly Beans, Licorice Pastels, Licorice...
  • Bright red, sugar-sanded Claey's Wild Cherry hard candy, approximately 75 pieces. Old fashioned retro cherry flavor.

    Claey's Hard Candy - Wild Cherry

    $5.65
    Claey's Hard Candy - Wild Cherry Bright red in color, these sweet, sugar-sanded, hard candies have a long lasting cherry flavor. Made in the USA, Claey's Hard Candy - Wild Cherry is the perfect nostalgic candy to satisfy your cherry candy craving. Each...
  • Bazooka Original Bubble Gum, individually wrapped pink pieces with classic red branding, approx 80 pieces per pound. Classic Bazooka Original Bubble Gum, individually wrapped in red, white, blue wrappers with Bazooka Joe comics, approx 80 pieces/lb.

    Bazooka Original Bubble Gum

    $8.55
    Bazooka Original Bubble GumBazooka Original Bubble Gum is the great American Bubble Gum! This classic bubble gum has been enjoyed for generations and is a favorite among old-fashioned candy lovers. Each piece of Bazooka Original Bubble Gum is...
  • Dubble Bubble Nostalgic Original 1928 flat chunk-shaped bubble gum, approx. 100 pieces with comics.

    Dubble Bubble Nostalgic Bubble Gum

    $13.95
    Dubble Bubble Nostalgic Bubble GumDubble Bubble Nostalgic Bubble Gum is a delightful blast from the past. Each piece of this bubble gum comes with a comic, just like in the good old days. Experience the nostalgic taste of the Original 1928 flat...
  • World Confections retro candy cigarettes, 8 sticks per pack, 24 packs per case, old-fashioned novelty candy. World Confections retro candy cigarettes, white sticks with red tips, 8 sticks per pack, 24 packs per case.

    Candy Cigarettes

    $9.65
    Candy CigarettesCandy cigarettes made by World Confections.  These candy cigarettes aren't just any ordinary candy - they're a blast from the past! These old-fashioned candies are reminiscent of the 1960s and will bring back memories for guests of all...
  • Goetze's Mini Caramel Cow Tales, 2.5-inch individually wrapped caramel candies with soft cream centers, approx 40 per pound. Goetze's Mini Caramel Cow Tales, soft cream center, golden brown caramel, 2.5 inches, wrapped, approx. 40 per pound.

    Mini Caramel Cow Tales

    $9.95
    Mini Caramel Cow TalesMini Caramel Cow Tales are the perfect sweet treat from Goetze's Candy. Enjoy the soft cream center & caramel coating in every bite. Indulge in the creamy taste of caramel candy with every bite you take. These mini cow tales are...
  • Boston Fruit Slices, large 5 lb box, colorful sugar-sanded fruit slices, assorted rainbow flavors, chewy candy. Boston Fruit Slices, large 5 lb box, sugar-sanded fruit slices, vibrant rainbow assortment.

    Boston Fruit Slices Large 5 Pound Box

    $27.95
    Boston Fruit Slices Large 5 Pound Box Boston Fruit Slices Large are classic soft and chewy sugar-sanded fruit slices that come in a delightful assortment of sweet fruity flavors. Each slice is bursting with the taste of orange, raspberry, lemon, lime,...
  • Claeys Horehound Hard Candy Drops, 6oz bag with approximately 42 dark brown, soothing, semi-sweet old fashioned pieces. Claeys Horehound hard candy drops, 6oz bag, approximately 42 old fashioned semi-sweet pieces.

    Claeys Hard Candy Drops Horehound 6oz Bag

    $2.75
    Claeys Hard Candy Drops Horehound 6oz Bag Claeys Hard Candy Drops Horehound 6oz Bag is the perfect nostalgic treat for those looking for a semi-sweet candy that is both flavorful and soothing. Made in the USA, these old fashioned hard candy drops are...
  • Sconza Boston Baked Beans, vibrant red crunchy candy shells covering peanuts, approx 360 per pound, old-fashioned USA candy. Sconza Boston Baked Beans candy, showcasing the textured, glossy red candy shells of the sweet peanuts

    Sconza Boston Baked Beans Candy

    $6.95
    Sconza Boston Baked Beans Candy Sconza Boston Baked Beans Candy is a delightful treat that combines the perfect balance of sweetness and saltiness. Each roasted peanut is coated in a crunchy candy shell, creating a unique and irresistible flavor...
  • Claeys Ginger Hard Candy, sugar-sanded drops. Light brown, natural ginger flavored, 75 pieces, Made in USA.

    Claeys Ginger Hard Candy

    $5.65
    Claeys Ginger Hard Candy Claey's Ginger Hard Candy is a delicious and nostalgic treat that will transport you back to the good old days. These sweet sugar-sanded hard candy drops are infused with a natural ginger flavor that is both refreshing and...
  • Boston Fruit Slices Mini, 5 lb box, vibrant rainbow colors, soft, chewy, sugar-sanded, orange, lemon, lime, cherry. Boston Fruit Slices Mini, 5 Pound Box, soft chewy sugar-sanded candy, vibrant rainbow orange, lemon, lime, cherry.

    Boston Fruit Slices Mini 5 Pound Box

    $27.95
    Boston Fruit Slices Mini 5 Pound Box Boston Fruit Slices Mini are classic soft and chewy sugar sanded fruit slices in an assortment of fruit flavors including orange, lemon, lime, and cherry. These mini fruit slices are about 1.5 inches wide by 1 inch...
  • Large gumdrops, vibrant rainbow colors, assorted cherry, orange, grape, lime, lemon, pineapple fruity flavors. Vibrant large gumdrops, assorted rainbow fruit flavors, cherry, orange, grape, lime, lemon, pineapple, USA made.

    Large Gumdrops

    $4.25
    Large GumdropsLarge Gumdrops - A retro candy favorite with assorted fruity flavors. Perfect for candy dishes and gingerbread house decorating. Order now! Large Gumdrops are a staple in the world of retro candy. These gumdrops are bursting with classic...
  • Claey's Hard Candy Drops, 6oz bag with approximately 42 yellow lemon hard candies. Claey's old-fashioned 6oz bag of yellow lemon hard candy drops, approximately 42 pieces, Made in USA.

    Claey's Hard Candy Drops Lemon 6oz Bag

    $2.75
    Claey's Hard Candy Drops Lemon 6oz Bag Clay's Hard Candy Drops Lemon 6oz Bag. Like the old fashioned hard candies? Why not enjoy Claeys Old Fashioned Hard Candies, full of Lemon flavor, in an old-fashioned bag? Approximately 42 pieces per bag. Made in...
  • Bright red, sugar sanded Claey's Watermelon Hard Candy drops, approx 75 pieces. Old fashioned, retro candy.

    Claey's Hard Candy - Watermelon

    $5.65
    Claey's Hard Candy - Watermelon Claey's Hard Candy - Watermelon is a delightful treat that will satisfy your sweet tooth with its refreshing watermelon flavor. These bright red, sugar sanded hard candies are perfect for parties or for indulging in a...
  • Total: items /

Adding your products to cart

View Cart Continue Shopping

All Old Fashioned Candy transports you to simpler, sweeter days, offering classic confections that evoke nostalgia and charm. Perfect for themed parties, vintage events, or simply reliving cherished childhood memories, these candies are beloved for their timeless flavors and traditional appeal. They're ideal for creating unique candy buffets, thoughtful retro party favors, or sharing stories across generations. Discover the enduring joy of Licorice Allsorts, with their distinctive shapes and chewy textures, or the satisfying snap and long-lasting flavor of classic Rock Candy sticks. Explore our collection and rediscover the sweet tastes of yesteryear!