All Old Fashioned Candy

Filter By

Sort By:

  • Product
  • Qty in Cart
  • Quantity
  • Price
  • Subtotal
  • Approximately 60 pieces of golden-brown sugar-free Chick O Stick Nuggets, classic peanut butter candy. Sugar-free Chick O Stick Nuggets, classic yellowish-brown peanut butter candy, 60 pieces per pound, Made in USA.

    Chick O Stick Nuggets Sugar Free

    $11.75
    Chick O Stick Nuggets Sugar Free Chick O Stick Nuggets Sugar Free is the classic peanut butter candy that has been loved by families since the 1950s. Previously known as "Chicken Bones", this nostalgic and delicious treat will make you fall in love with...
  • Jelly Belly Licorice Pastels, light green, yellow, purple, red, black, white, 1lb, 1200pc, crunchy black licorice.
    Out of Stock
    Out of Stock

    Jelly Belly Licorice Pastels

    $15.05
    Jelly Belly Licorice PastelsJelly Belly Licorice Pastels are a timeless candy treat that is perfect for nostalgic candy lovers. This delicious black licorice candy boasts a crunchy candy shell that gives way to a wonderful old-world licorice flavor...
  • Vibrant red Bubble Gum Cigarettes, 24 pieces per pack, with 8 assorted nostalgic labels. Vibrant red bubble gum cigarettes, 24-count pack, 8 unique labels, classic bubblegum flavor, nostalgic retro candy.

    Bubble Gum Cigarettes

    $23.65
    Bubble Gum CigarettesBubble Gum Cigarettes - The only harmless cigarettes you can find...ones made of bubble gum! Indulge in a nostalgic treat with these Bubble Gum Cigarettes. Each pack contains 24 bubble gum cigarettes with 8 different labels. With...
  • Spearmint Rito Mints, pastel green, bite-sized, 3/4 inch diameter, approximately 100 mints per pound, old-fashioned candy.

    Spearmint Rito Mints

    $7.45
    Spearmint Rito Mints Experience the refreshing taste of Spearmint Rito Mints. These pastel green candies are the perfect treat for anyone who loves old-fashioned candies with a hint of minty goodness. Each bite-sized mint is approximately 3/4 inch in...
  • Goldenberg Peanut Chews, rich milk chocolate coating, chewy roasted nuts, approximately 50 mini pieces. Goldenberg Peanut Chews, rich brown milk chocolate, chewy nuts, approx 50 mini candies per pound.

    Goldenberg Peanut Chews Milk Chocolate

    $6.95
    Goldenberg Peanut Chews Milk ChocolateIntroduced in 1917, the Original Goldenberg's Peanut Chews consist of a chewy center full of roasted nuts and covered in a rich milk chocolatey coating, making them a perfect snack. Each piece is 0.3oz, with...
  • Classic Big League Chew Swingin Sour Apple shredded green bubble gum, tangy apple flavor, nostalgic candy treat. Big League Chew Swingin Sour Apple shredded bubble gum pack, vibrant green, tangy sour apple flavor.

    Big League Chew Bubble Gum Swingin Sour Apple

    $2.15
    Big League Chew Swingin Sour Apple Swingin Sour Apple is a classic chewing gum that keeps the tradition alive. Whether you're an athlete, a fan, or simply someone who enjoys a sweet treat, this shredded gum is the perfect companion to keep your mouth...
  • Zachary JuJu Coins, 1-inch assorted red, orange, yellow, green fruity candies with dollar signs. Assorted JuJu Coins by Zachary, 1-inch. Red, orange, yellow, green fruit-flavored candies with dollar symbols.

    JuJu Coins - Assorted

    $5.25
    JuJu Coins - AssortedJuju Coins Assorted is a delightful candy that offers a burst of fruity flavors in every bite. Made by Zachary, a renowned brand in the candy industry, this candy is a must-have for all candy lovers. With a texture that is slightly...
  • Vibrant red Primrose Strawberry Hard Candies, classic, old-fashioned, about 66 per pound, individually strawberry-foil wrapped. Vibrant red Primrose Strawberry Hard Candies, classic, old-fashioned, about 66 per pound, individually strawberry-foil wrapped.
    Out of Stock
    Out of Stock

    Strawberry Hard Candy

    $7.45
    Strawberry Hard Candy Strawberry Hard Candy is a delightful treat for candy lovers of all ages. Made by Primrose Candy, this classic confection features a delicious strawberry filling wrapped in bright foils that resemble strawberries. Each batch is...
  • Vibrant red, square Strawberry Shortcake taffy. Approx 45 chewy pieces per pound, bulk. Vibrant red Strawberry Shortcake Taffy, chewy square pieces, rich strawberry flavor, approx. 45 pieces per pound.

    Strawberry Shortcake Taffy

    $7.45
    Strawberry Shortcake TaffyStrawberry Shortcake Taffy is an amazing retro candy that is sure to bring back childhood memories. These square pieces of chewy taffy perfection have a rich strawberry flavor that will transport you to a sweet trip down memory...
  • Ferrara Boston Baked Beans candy, 24-pack, 0.8oz red candy-coated peanuts. Classic old-fashioned retro crunchy sweets. Boston Baked Beans candy, 24 individual boxes of reddish-brown candy-coated peanuts with sweet crunchy shells.

    Boston Baked Beans Candy 24 Pack

    $11.75
    Boston Baked Beans Candy 24 Pack Boston Baked Beans 24 pack. Classic candy-coated peanuts. These "Original" Boston Baked Beans are an old-fashioned candy favorite, with a sweet crunchy candy shell. Each box is 0.8oz, 24 boxes per order. Old Fashioned...
  • Brown and off-white mini Big Hunk candy bars, individually wrapped. Chewy honey nougat, whole roasted peanuts. 28 per pound.
    Out of Stock
    Out of Stock

    Big Hunk Candy Bars

    $12.85
    Big Hunk Candy BarsBig Hunk Candy Bars - A true retro candy classic, this bar has a chewy honey-sweetened nougat with whole roasted peanuts. Wrapped and ready to go in bite-size pieces. Approx 28 Mini Big Hunk Candy Bars per pound. Made in the USA.This...
  • Atkinson Long Boys, individually wrapped creamy golden caramel coconut candies, approx 40 per pound. Atkinson Long Boys, creamy caramel coconut candy, individually wrapped, light brown color, approx 40 pieces.

    Long Boys Candy

    $8.55
    Long Boys Candy Long Boys Candy - Creamy caramel infused with real coconut flakes and individually wrapped. Approximately 40 Long Boys per pound. Made in the USA. Old Fashioned Candy Caramel Candy Coconut Candy Atkinson Candy Made in the USA Candy
  • Big League Chew, approx 70 individually wrapped pink gumballs, 1lb bag, Outta' Here Original flavor. Pink Big League Chew gumballs, individually wrapped, Outta' Here Original flavor, approx. 70 per 1-lb bag.

    Big League Chew Gumballs

    $4.95
    Big League Chew Gumballs The Ultimate Dugout Classic Elevate your game day ritual with Big League Chew Gumballs. While the brand is famous for its shredded texture, these individually wrapped gumballs offer a convenient, mess-free way to enjoy the Outta'...
  • Vibrant yellow Abba Zaba Mini candy bars, taffy exterior, rich peanut butter center. Approx 38 pieces per pound.
    Out of Stock
    Out of Stock

    Abba Zaba Candy Bars - Mini

    $12.85
    Abba Zaba Candy Bars - MiniAbba Zaba Candy Bars - Mini. Get the retro taste with a taffy outside and rich peanut butter center. Order now for the best prices on bulk candy!Abba Zaba Candy Bars - Mini, starting in 1922, are truly something wonderful! This...
  • Marpole Marshmallow Twists, 8 soft pastel colored twisted marshmallow poles, individually wrapped in a bag. Marpole Marshmallow Twists, 8 individually wrapped soft twisted poles in pastel colors.

    Marpole Marshmallow Twist Bag

    $3.15
    Marpole Marshmallow Twist Bag Marpole Marshmallow Twists are a classic nostalgic candy treat! These soft twisted marshmallow poles in pastel colors are individually wrapped. Each bag contains 8 individually wrapped marpoles. Perfect for Easter baskets,...
  • Eda's Old Time Mix Sugar Free Hard Candy. Assorted red, brown, white, and dark candies, 8 nostalgic flavors, approx 80 pieces per pound.

    Eda's Old Time Mix Sugar Free Candy

    $11.75
    Eda's Old Time Mix Sugar Free CandyEda's Old Time Mix Sugar Free Candy is a nostalgic assortment that brings back memories of the good old days. This fun mix includes a variety of flavors such as Peppermint, Butterscotch, Root Beer, Coffee, Chocolate,...
  • Giant Gumdrops, classic fruit flavors, sugar-coated, rainbow mix white, red, green, yellow, orange, purple. Approx 45 per lb. Giant Gumdrops, old-fashioned, sugar-coated, assorted fruit flavors. White, red, green, yellow, orange, dark purple, approx 45 per lb.

    Giant Gumdrops - Land of the Gummies

    $4.25
    Giant GumdropsGiant Gumdrops are a classic and nostalgic candy that will take you back to your childhood. These old-fashioned gumdrops come in a variety of fruit flavors and are coated in tasty sugar crystals. The colors include white, red, green,...
  • Lemonheads mini sour lemon candy, 24 individual yellow packs, fun size retro treat. 24 mini Lemonheads candy packs, sour lemon flavor, in cute yellow boxes. Retro and fun size 0.8oz packs.

    Lemonheads 24 Pack

    $11.75
    Lemonheads 24 PackLemonheads 24 Pack. These mini Lemonheads are nice and sour and easily transportable in this cute yellow box! Great changemaker candies. Each display box contains 24 packs of Lemonheads candy, packs are .8oz.Old Fashioned CandyRetro...
  • Brightly colored, sugar-sanded Claey's Sassafras hard candy drops, approx 75 per pound. Retro, Made in USA.

    Claey's Hard Candy - Sassafras

    $5.65
    Claey's Hard Candy - Sassafras Claey's Hard Candy - Sassafras is a brightly colored, sugar sanded, hard candy with a delightful sassafras flavor. Transport yourself back in time and indulge in the nostalgic taste of these delicious candies. Similar in...
  • Wonka Fun Dip, 48 individual packs. Red Cherry Yum Diddly Dip and blue Razz Apple Magic Dip powder candy. 48 Fun Dip packs, Cherry Yum Diddly Dip, Razz Apple Magic Dip. Vibrant red & blue nostalgic Wonka candy.

    Fun Dip 48 pack

    $13.95
    Fun DipFun Dip - Good old fashioned fun with Fun Dip! A great choice for party treat bags, Easter baskets, and stocking stuffers. Fun Dip contains two flavors Cherry Yum Diddly Dip and Razz Apple Magic Dip. 48 Fun Dip Packs per box.Fun Dip is the perfect...
  • Totally 90s retro candy box with over 45 assorted pieces, including colorful Ring Pop, Fun Dip, Pop Rocks, Nerds, Gummy Pizza.

    Totally 90's Candy Box

    $26.85
    Totally 90's Candy BoxTotally 1990's Candy Box This retro candy box contains candies that were popular during the 1990's. Each box contains over 45 pieces of 90's candy including: Creme Savers, Ring Pop, Fun Dip, Pop Rocks, Cry Baby Gumballs, Nerds,...
  • Classic Sixlets. Vibrant, bite-sized, rainbow chocolate candies with crisp shells and rich centers for nostalgic snacking. Vibrant rainbow Sixlets candy, a pile of classic bite-sized chocolate pieces with crisp shells.

    Sixlets

    $10.65
    Sixlets Add a pop of color and a burst of nostalgia with Sixlets — the classic candy that’s making a comeback! These bite-sized, colorful candies feature a crisp candy shell and a rich, chocolatey center that customers of all ages love. Perfect for candy...
  • 20 pack retro chewing gum assortment, 5 packs each of Beemans, Clove, Black Jack, and Teaberry gum. 20 pack retro chewing gum assortment, 5 packs each of Beemans, Clove, Black Jack, and Teaberry gum.

    Beemans, Clove, Black Jack, and Teaberry Chewing Gum 20 Pack

    $13.95
    Beemans, Clove, Black Jack, and Teaberry Chewing Gum 20 PackBeemans, Clove, Black Jack, and Teaberry Chewing Gum 20 Pack. That's right, with the reintroduction of Teaberry, we're putting the band back together! Enjoy this amazing assortment of your...
  • Red and green striped Christmas chocolate straws, 2-inch, crispy, creamy chocolate-filled, old-fashioned. Old Fashioned Christmas chocolate straws, shiny red & green striped, 2-inch, crispy, creamy chocolate filling.

    Old Fashioned Christmas Chocolate Straws

    $15.95
    Old Fashioned Christmas Chocolate StrawsOld Fashioned Christmas Chocolate Straws are a delightful holiday treat that will surely bring back memories of nostalgic Christmases past. These shiny red and green striped chocolate straws are light-weight,...
  • Mary Jane Fun Size twist wrap candies, 57 pieces, yellow and red wrappers, sweet molasses and peanut butter flavor. Mary Jane Fun Size twist wrap candy, brown molasses peanut butter flavor, approx 57 pieces per pound, USA made.

    Mary Jane Candy Fun Size

    $9.65
    Mary Jane Candy Fun Size The Mary Jane Candy Fun Size is a delicious twist wrap candy with the perfect blend of Molasses and Peanut Butter flavors. Originally made in 1914 by the Charles N. Miller Company, this candy was named after Charles' favorite...
  • Retro 1950s candy box, 2lb, 50 assorted individual candies. Colorful Sugar Daddy, Smarties, Jawbreakers, Wax Lips mix.

    Old Fashioned Candy Box Back to the 1950's

    $26.85
    Old Fashioned Candy Box Back to the 1950's Celebrate the 1950's with this retro candy box bursting with candies popular during the decade.  These boxes make a great gift to celebrate a 50's birthday, or anytime you want to take a 'sweet' walk down...
  • Nostalgic Concord Confections Wax Sticks, approximately 40 rainbow-colored fruit liquid candy sticks, 4-inch chewy treat.
    Out of Stock
    Out of Stock

    Wax Sticks

    $7.05
    Wax SticksWax Sticks are a nostalgic candy that brings back memories of the past. These candy sticks are filled with a flavorful fruit liquid that bursts with every bite. Each stick measures approximately 4 1/4 - 4 1/2 inches long and there are...
  • Colorful mini English licorice allsorts, black licorice pieces in assorted shapes, approx 200 per pound. Vibrant, colorful mini Licorice Allsorts, an assortment of firm black licorice in various shapes, approximately 200 pieces.
    Out of Stock
    Out of Stock

    Mini Licorice Allsorts

    $8.15
    Mini Licorice AllsortsMini Licorice Allsorts are the perfect treat for any licorice lover! These firm black licorice pieces come in an assortment of shapes and textures, all in a colorful mini size. Enjoy the classic licorice taste in these bright and...
  • Candy Buttons, classic colorful candy dots on paper, 24 individually wrapped bags, rainbow fruit flavors. Box of 24 individually wrapped classic Candy Buttons, colorful candy dots on paper strips.

    Candy Buttons Box 24 Piece

    $25.85
    Candy Buttons Box 24 PieceStep back in time and rediscover the classic joy of Candy Buttons – those delightful candy dots on paper that bring back fond memories of childhood fun!Each colorful strip is adorned with vibrant candy buttons, ready to be...
  • Chewy Long Boys Junior caramel and coconut candy, golden-brown with visible white flakes, approximately 85 pieces per pound. Golden brown Long Boys Junior candy, chewy caramel with white coconut flakes, approx 85 bite-sized pieces per pound.

    Long Boys Junior Candy

    $7.95
    Long Boys Junior CandyLong Boys Junior Candy is an old-fashioned chewy treat that combines creamy caramel with coconut flakes. Made in the USA, this candy offers a blissful experience with each bite. Each pound of Long Boys Junior Candy includes...
  • Claeys Raspberry Hard Candy Drops, 6oz bag, approx 42 red, old-fashioned hard candy pieces.

    Claeys Hard Candy Drops Raspberry 6oz Bag

    $2.75
    Claeys Hard Candy Drops Raspberry 6oz Bag Claeys Hard Candy Drops Raspberry 6oz Bag. Old-fashioned hard candy full of Raspberry flavor. Approximately 42 pieces per bag. Made in the USA. Perfect for candy lovers. Order now and satisfy your sweet...
  • Old fashioned pastel chocolate straws, assorted colors, 2 inch crispy Christmas candy, smooth chocolate filling. Old Fashioned Pastel Chocolate Straws, assorted colors, 2 inch crispy shell, smooth chocolate inside, USA made Christmas candy.
    Out of Stock
    Out of Stock

    Old Fashioned Pastel Chocolate Straws

    $15.95
    Old Fashioned Pastel Chocolate StrawsOld Fashioned Pastel Chocolate Straws - Lightweight, crispy shell filled with a smooth chocolatey inside. These chocolate straws come in an assortment of pastel colors. Great old-fashioned Christmas Candy for your...
  • 100 individual, foil-wrapped brown Ice Cubes Chocolate Candy pieces, bulk German 1-inch cube chocolates. 100 individually wrapped Albert's Ice Cubes Chocolate Candy, dark brown 1-inch velvety cubes, classic German bulk treat.
    Out of Stock
    Out of Stock

    Ice Cubes Chocolate Candy 100 Piece

    $42.95
    Ice Cubes Chocolate Candy 100 Piece Ice Cubes Chocolate Candy 100 Piece are sweet treats that melts in your mouth. Ice Cubes Candy has a velvety chocolate bite and feels cool to the tongue, making them a unique treat. It’s no wonder they’ve been around...
  • Claeys Hard Candy 10x 6oz assorted bags. Classic flavors like red cherry, yellow lemon, green apple, brown root beer drops.

    Claeys Hard Candy Assorted Bags 10 Pack

    $23.65
    Claeys Hard Candy Assorted Bags 10 PackClaeys Hard Candy Drops Assorted Bags 10 Pack offers a delightful variety of Claeys Old Fashioned Hard Candy bags, perfect for satisfying any sweet tooth. Each bag contains an assortment of classic flavors,...
  • Charms Sour Balls Tin, retro metal design, filled with many colorful assorted fruit sour candies, red cherry, green lime.

    Charms Sour Balls Tin

    $6.95
    Charms Sour Balls TinCharms Sour Balls Tin is the perfect treat for anyone with a sour tooth. These delicious sour balls come in assorted fruit flavors that will tantalize your taste buds and leave you craving for more.  The retro design of the tin adds...
  • Gilliam Stick Candy, 80 red and white striped old fashioned peppermint hard candy sticks, each 5 inches long. 80 Gilliam Old Fashioned Peppermint hard candy sticks, 5-inch, red and white striped, individually wrapped.

    Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Peppermint 80 Sticks

    $25.85
    Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Peppermint 80 Sticks Enjoy the classic taste of red and white striped candy sticks with Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Peppermint! These nostalgic treats bring back the flavors of the past. Made by Gilliam Candy...
  • 1970s Old Fashioned Candy Box with over 50 colorful retro candies like Blowpops, Nerds, Pop Rocks, Laffy Taffy. 1970s Old Fashioned Candy Box with over 50 colorful retro candies like Blowpops, Nerds, Pop Rocks, Laffy Taffy.

    Old Fashioned Candy Box Get Down with the 1970's

    $26.85
    Old Fashioned Candy Box Get Down with the 1970's Get down with the candies from the 1970's.  This treat box contains candies that were popular during the 1970's.  Each box contains over 50 pieces of candy, including: Blowpop, Zotz, ...
  • 36 Vanilla Charleston Chews, yellow display box, chocolate-coated vanilla nougat retro candy bars. Vanilla Charleston Chews, 36 white vanilla nougat pieces with chocolatey coating in a yellow display box.

    Vanilla Charleston Chews Changemaker 36 Piece

    $15.95
    Vanilla Charleston Chews Changemaker 36 PieceVanilla Charleston Chews Changemaker 36 Piece is a delicious treat that combines vanilla nougat with a chocolatey coating. Named after the popular 1920's dance, the Charleston, this candy bar is perfect for...
  • Marpro Yum Yum Marshmallow Ice Cream Cones, 24 packs, 48 total cones. Fluffy white marshmallows, crunchy brown waffle cone pieces. Marpro Yum Yum Marshmallow Ice Cream Cones, 48 pastel, fluffy white marshmallows & crunchy waffle cones.

    Marpro Yum Yum Marshmallow Ice Cream Cones 24 Piece

    $13.95
    Marpro Yum Yum Marshmallow Ice Cream Cones 24 Piece Marpro Yum Yum Marshmallow Ice Cream Cones 24 Piece have been enjoyed by candy lovers since 1936. These candy cones are made with fluffy marshmallows and crunchy waffle cone pieces, creating a...
  • Old Fashioned 1960s retro candy box, 2lb, over 30 individually wrapped nostalgic candies, colorful assortment.

    Old Fashioned Candy Box Candy Love 1960's

    $26.85
    Old Fashioned Candy Box Candy & Love 1960's Celebrate the Candy and Love with this 1960's retro treat box.   Each box contains candies that were popular during the 1960s.  These boxes make a great gift to celebrate a 60's birthday, or...
  • Total: items /

Adding your products to cart

View Cart Continue Shopping

All Old Fashioned Candy transports you to simpler, sweeter days, offering classic confections that evoke nostalgia and charm. Perfect for themed parties, vintage events, or simply reliving cherished childhood memories, these candies are beloved for their timeless flavors and traditional appeal. They're ideal for creating unique candy buffets, thoughtful retro party favors, or sharing stories across generations. Discover the enduring joy of Licorice Allsorts, with their distinctive shapes and chewy textures, or the satisfying snap and long-lasting flavor of classic Rock Candy sticks. Explore our collection and rediscover the sweet tastes of yesteryear!