All Old Fashioned Candy

All Old Fashioned Candy transports you to simpler, sweeter days, offering classic confections that evoke nostalgia and charm. Perfect for themed parties, vintage events, or simply reliving cherished childhood memories, these candies are beloved for their timeless flavors and traditional appeal. They're ideal for creating unique candy buffets, thoughtful retro party favors, or sharing stories across generations. Discover the enduring joy of Licorice Allsorts, with their distinctive shapes and chewy textures, or the satisfying snap and long-lasting flavor of classic Rock Candy sticks. Explore our collection and rediscover the sweet tastes of yesteryear!

Filter By

Sort By:

Filters
  • Product
  • Qty in Cart
  • Quantity
  • Price
  • Subtotal
  • Image of Iconic Retro Sours Tangerine Image of Iconic Retro Sours Tangerine 8 Pack

    Iconic Retro Sours Tangerine 8 pack

    $19.95
    Iconic Retro Sours Tangerine 8 Pack Get ready for a citrus blast from the past with Iconic Retro Sours – Tangerine! These bold, zesty hard candies combine the bright, juicy flavor of tangerine with a perfectly puckering sour twist that wakes up...
  • image of sugar daddy candy bulk bars retro caramel old fashioned

    Sugar Daddy Candy 24 Piece

    $44.95
    Sugar Daddy Candy 24 PieceThe Sugar Daddy Candy 24 Piece is a delicious milk caramel pops that will take you back to sweet memories of the past. This classic retro candy is a must-have for any candy lover. Each box contains 24 pieces of the mouthwatering...
  • image of cashew brittle bulk unwrapped candy fathers day old fashioned toffee sweet and salty
    Out of Stock
    Out of Stock

    Cashew Brittle

    $9.95
    Cashew BrittleCashew Brittle is a delicious candy treat that will satisfy your sweet tooth and leave you craving more. Made by Old Dominion Peanut, a trusted brand since 1913, this buttery toffee candy is a must-have for any candy lover. With its...
  • image of chick o stick retro candy atkinson coconut old fashioned gluten free s
    Out of Stock
    Out of Stock

    Chick O Stick 36 Piece

    $14.95
    Chick O Stick 36 Piece Chick O Stick 36 Piece The old \Chicken Bones\ candy has a new name but the recipe is still the same, these crunchy peanut candies are sprinkled with toasted coconut and come in a 36 count box for your enjoyment! Made in the USA...
  • Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Passion Fruit 80 Sticks

    Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Passion Fruit 80 Sticks

    $23.95
    Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Passion Fruit 80 SticksGilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Passion Fruit 80 sticks. Retro candy sticks like you would find at an old fashioned penny candy store. Each beautifully striped hard candy stick is individually...
  • image of jujyfruits theater box movie candy chewy retro old fashioned juju

    Jujyfruits Theater Box 12 Pack

    $22.95
    Jujyfruits Theater Box 12 PackJujyfruits Theater Box 12 Pack.  Since the 1920s, candy lovers have been enjoying this chewy fruity candy.  This retro candy classic still comes in all your favorite flavors:  Red Raspberry, Orange, Yellow Lemon, Green...
  • image of pop rocks cherry red candy old fashioned concession stand

    Pop Rocks Cherry 24 Pack

    $19.95
    Pop Rocks Cherry 24 PackPop Rocks Cherry 24 Pack. These Cherry Pop Rocks come in the original packaging from the 1970's. Great for your Retro Candy display. Fun Fact: Pop Rocks were introduced in the 1970’s, selling 500 million packages in only 18...
  • image of sugar babies bulk candy bars old fashioned gluten free caramel
    Out of Stock
    Out of Stock

    Sugar Babies 1.7 oz 24 Pack

    $45.95
    Sugar Babies 1.7 oz 24 PackBite-sized, chewy caramel candies coated in a sweet sugary shell are what you can expect from the Sugar Babies. Perfect for candy lovers of all ages, this nostalgic treat offers convenience and flavor in every bite. The...
  • image of wax lips old fashioned candy image of wax lips old fashioned candy

    Wax Lips

    $38.95
    Wax LipsWax Lips are a fun and silly novelty candy that make the perfect old-fashioned Valentine's present. These wack-o wax lips are sure to bring a smile to anyone's face and are great for the whole family to enjoy. With 24 wax lips per pack, you'll...
  • image of blue laffy taffy candy raspberry parade

    Blue Laffy Taffy

    $19.95
    Blue Laffy TaffyBlue Laffy Taffy: Bursting with Blue Raspberry flavor, each wrapper features a joke! 145 pieces per order, Made in the USA. Order Now!Blue Laffy Taffy Old time favorite Laffy Taffy is juicy, tangy, and bursting with Blue Raspberry flavor...
  • image of flying saucer bulk candy unwrapped novelty gerrit verburg non gmo old fashioned
    Out of Stock
    Out of Stock

    Flying Saucer Candy - Satellite Wafers

    $19.95
    Flying Saucer Candy - Satellite WafersFlying Saucer Candy - Satellite Wafers Enjoy the extraterrestrial experience of Gerrit's Satellite Wafers. These unique confections are a journey to outer space, where crispy wafers meet colorful candy beads for an...
  • image of gilliam stick candy old fashioned birthday cake sticks rainbow

    Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Birthday Cake 80 Sticks

    $22.95
    Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Birthday Cake 80 SticksGilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Birthday Cake 80 sticks. Retro candy sticks like you would find at an old fashioned penny candy store. Each beautifully rainbow-striped hard candy stick is...
  • image of gilliam stick candy old fashioned bubble gum sticks hard retro

    Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Bubble Gum 80 Sticks

    $22.95
    Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Bubble Gum 80 sticksGilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Bubble Gum is a delightful treat that will take you back in time. This retro candy is reminiscent of the colorful and delicious candy sticks you would find at an...
  • image of gilliam stick candy old fashioned butterscotch sticks hard retro yellow

    Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Butterscotch 80 Sticks

    $22.95
    Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Butterscotch 80 SticksGilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Butterscotch is a must-have for lovers of retro candy and those looking to indulge their sweet tooth. The yellow, butterscotch flavor is a crowd-pleaser that will...
  • image of a candy box of candy made in the 80s old fashioned retro gift box 1980s

    Made in the 1980's Retro Candy Box

    $24.95
    Made in the 1980's Retro Candy BoxTravel back to the future with Candy Nation.  Pop a mix tape in your boombox and enjoy some retro candy from the 1980's.  This treat box contains 2lb of candies that were popular in the 1980's. The assortment includes...
  • Total: items /

Adding your products to cart