All Old Fashioned Candy

Filter By

Sort By:

  • Product
  • Qty in Cart
  • Quantity
  • Price
  • Subtotal
  • Cavalier Candies red, green, white striped hard mints. Classic Christmas candy, approx 90 per pound.
    Out of Stock
    Out of Stock

    Red Green and White Striped Mint

    $8.15
    Red Green and White Striped MintRed, Green, and White Striped Mints are a classic Christmas candy that brings joy and festivity to any occasion. These hard mints feature a delightful minty flavor that is sure to refresh your taste buds.Each pound of this...
  • Tart N Tinys retro sour candy, colorful rainbow fruit flavors: cherry, orange, lemon, grape, lime. Bite-sized pellets. Tiny, colorful Tart N Tinys retro candy pellets. Rainbow of cherry, orange, lemon, grape, lime fruit flavors. Stackable, uncoated.

    Tart N Tinys

    $15.05
    Tart N Tinys Tart N Tinys, the bite-sized retro candy that packs a punch of tangy sweetness, are back! These nostalgic little pellets come in a rainbow of fruity flavors—think cherry, orange, lemon, grape, and lime—each one bursting with a...
  • Giant Gumdrops, plump old fashioned fruit jelly candy. Sugar-coated, a colorful mix: white, red, green, yellow, orange, dark purple. Plump, assorted colorful giant gumdrops, sugar-coated retro jelly candy, white, red, green, yellow, orange, dark purple, 45 per pound.

    Giant Gumdrops

    $3.95
    Giant Gumdrops Giant Gumdrops are the old fashioned gumdrops you remember! These plump, retro jelly candies come in a variety of fruit flavors and have a perfect texture. Just like the old candy you remember, these are coated in tasty sugar crystals...
  • Creme Savers Strawberry & Creme hard candy, red and white swirled, 6.25oz bag of individually wrapped retro candies. Creme Savers Strawberry & Creme hard candy 6.25oz bag, red and white swirled, individually wrapped pieces.

    Creme Savers Strawberry & Creme Hard Candy 6.25oz Bag

    $5.25
    Creme Savers Strawberry & Creme Hard Candy 6.25oz Bag Creme Savers are back! Remember the sweet taste of fresh strawberries swirled in delicious cream? Taste the nostalgia in each piece of individually wrapped Strawberry Creme Saver perfection. Order...
  • A 6-ounce bag of Claeys Hard Candy Drops Wild Cherry, showing the classic paper packaging filled with sugar-sanded red hard candies Claeys Wild Cherry drops deep red Wild Cherry hard candy drops dusted in fine sanding sugar, highlighting their smooth oval shape

    Claey's Hard Candy Drops Wild Cherry 6oz Bag

    $2.75
    Claey's Hard Candy Drops Wild Cherry 6oz Bag Claeys Old Fashioned Wild Cherry Hard Candy Drops deliver a vibrant, mouthwatering cherry flavor that has been loved by generations. Since 1919, Claeys Candies has been producing premium, smooth-textured...
  • Approximately 60 pieces of golden-brown sugar-free Chick O Stick Nuggets, classic peanut butter candy. Sugar-free Chick O Stick Nuggets, classic yellowish-brown peanut butter candy, 60 pieces per pound, Made in USA.

    Chick O Stick Nuggets Sugar Free

    $11.75
    Chick O Stick Nuggets Sugar Free Chick O Stick Nuggets Sugar Free is the classic peanut butter candy that has been loved by families since the 1950s. Previously known as "Chicken Bones", this nostalgic and delicious treat will make you fall in love with...
  • Vibrant red Bubble Gum Cigarettes, 24 pieces per pack, with 8 assorted nostalgic labels. Vibrant red bubble gum cigarettes, 24-count pack, 8 unique labels, classic bubblegum flavor, nostalgic retro candy.

    Bubble Gum Cigarettes

    $23.65
    Bubble Gum CigarettesBubble Gum Cigarettes - The only harmless cigarettes you can find...ones made of bubble gum! Indulge in a nostalgic treat with these Bubble Gum Cigarettes. Each pack contains 24 bubble gum cigarettes with 8 different labels. With...
  • Jelly Belly Licorice Pastels, light green, yellow, purple, red, black, white, 1lb, 1200pc, crunchy black licorice.
    Out of Stock
    Out of Stock

    Jelly Belly Licorice Pastels

    $15.05
    Jelly Belly Licorice PastelsJelly Belly Licorice Pastels are a timeless candy treat that is perfect for nostalgic candy lovers. This delicious black licorice candy boasts a crunchy candy shell that gives way to a wonderful old-world licorice flavor...
  • Classic Big League Chew Swingin Sour Apple shredded green bubble gum, tangy apple flavor, nostalgic candy treat. Big League Chew Swingin Sour Apple shredded bubble gum pack, vibrant green, tangy sour apple flavor.

    Big League Chew Bubble Gum Swingin Sour Apple

    $2.15
    Big League Chew Swingin Sour Apple Swingin Sour Apple is a classic chewing gum that keeps the tradition alive. Whether you're an athlete, a fan, or simply someone who enjoys a sweet treat, this shredded gum is the perfect companion to keep your mouth...
  • Spearmint Rito Mints, pastel green, bite-sized, 3/4 inch diameter, approximately 100 mints per pound, old-fashioned candy.

    Spearmint Rito Mints

    $7.85
    Spearmint Rito Mints Experience the refreshing taste of Spearmint Rito Mints. These pastel green candies are the perfect treat for anyone who loves old-fashioned candies with a hint of minty goodness. Each bite-sized mint is approximately 3/4 inch in...
  • Goldenberg Peanut Chews, rich milk chocolate coating, chewy roasted nuts, approximately 50 mini pieces. Goldenberg Peanut Chews, rich brown milk chocolate, chewy nuts, approx 50 mini candies per pound.

    Goldenberg Peanut Chews Milk Chocolate

    $6.95
    Goldenberg Peanut Chews Milk ChocolateIntroduced in 1917, the Original Goldenberg's Peanut Chews consist of a chewy center full of roasted nuts and covered in a rich milk chocolatey coating, making them a perfect snack. Each piece is 0.3oz, with...
  • Zachary JuJu Coins, 1-inch assorted red, orange, yellow, green fruity candies with dollar signs. Assorted JuJu Coins by Zachary, 1-inch. Red, orange, yellow, green fruit-flavored candies with dollar symbols.

    JuJu Coins - Assorted

    $5.25
    JuJu Coins - AssortedJuju Coins Assorted is a delightful candy that offers a burst of fruity flavors in every bite. Made by Zachary, a renowned brand in the candy industry, this candy is a must-have for all candy lovers. With a texture that is slightly...
  • Vibrant red Primrose Strawberry Hard Candies, classic, old-fashioned, about 66 per pound, individually strawberry-foil wrapped. Vibrant red Primrose Strawberry Hard Candies, classic, old-fashioned, about 66 per pound, individually strawberry-foil wrapped.
    Out of Stock
    Out of Stock

    Strawberry Hard Candy

    $7.45
    Strawberry Hard Candy Strawberry Hard Candy is a delightful treat for candy lovers of all ages. Made by Primrose Candy, this classic confection features a delicious strawberry filling wrapped in bright foils that resemble strawberries. Each batch is...
  • Vibrant red, square Strawberry Shortcake taffy. Approx 45 chewy pieces per pound, bulk. Vibrant red Strawberry Shortcake Taffy, chewy square pieces, rich strawberry flavor, approx. 45 pieces per pound.

    Strawberry Shortcake Taffy

    $7.45
    Strawberry Shortcake TaffyStrawberry Shortcake Taffy is an amazing retro candy that is sure to bring back childhood memories. These square pieces of chewy taffy perfection have a rich strawberry flavor that will transport you to a sweet trip down memory...
  • Ferrara Boston Baked Beans candy, 24-pack, 0.8oz red candy-coated peanuts. Classic old-fashioned retro crunchy sweets. Boston Baked Beans candy, 24 individual boxes of reddish-brown candy-coated peanuts with sweet crunchy shells.

    Boston Baked Beans Candy 24 Pack

    $11.75
    Boston Baked Beans Candy 24 Pack Boston Baked Beans 24 pack. Classic candy-coated peanuts. These "Original" Boston Baked Beans are an old-fashioned candy favorite, with a sweet crunchy candy shell. Each box is 0.8oz, 24 boxes per order. Old Fashioned...
  • Total: items /

Adding your products to cart

View Cart Continue Shopping

All Old Fashioned Candy transports you to simpler, sweeter days, offering classic confections that evoke nostalgia and charm. Perfect for themed parties, vintage events, or simply reliving cherished childhood memories, these candies are beloved for their timeless flavors and traditional appeal. They're ideal for creating unique candy buffets, thoughtful retro party favors, or sharing stories across generations. Discover the enduring joy of Licorice Allsorts, with their distinctive shapes and chewy textures, or the satisfying snap and long-lasting flavor of classic Rock Candy sticks. Explore our collection and rediscover the sweet tastes of yesteryear!