- Product
- Qty in Cart
- Quantity
- Price
- Subtotal
-
Pink Wintergreen Mints
$7.45Pink Wintergreen Mints Wintergreen Mints is a timeless classic that never goes out of style. With its refreshing flavor and delightful pink color, our Pink Wintergreen Mints are sure to satisfy your... -
Peanut Brittle
$8.55Peanut Brittle Peanut Brittle - Crispy, Crunchy, and Fresh Peanut Brittle! This salty and sweet candy melts in your mouth! Peanut Brittle is an old-fashioned candy favorite in various shapes and... -
Dads Root Beer Barrels Sugar Free Candy
$13.95Dad's Root Beer Barrels Sugar Free CandyTake a trip down memory lane with the Dad's Root Beer Barrels Sugar Free Candy! This nostalgic treat is perfect for those who love the classic taste of root... -
The Original Banana Split Candy Chews
$7.45The Original Banana Split Candy Chews The Original Banana Split Candy Chews is a fantastic retro candy that is back! Made with square pieces of chewy taffy perfection, this candy offers a rich banana... -
Claeys Cinnamon Old Fashioned Hard Candy
$5.65Claeys Cinnamon Old Fashioned Hard Candy Claeys Cinnamon Old Fashioned Hard Candy is the perfect treat to satisfy your cinnamon cravings. These sweet and spicy candies are sugar sanded and provide a... -
Leman's Mint Hard Candy
$10.65Leman's Mint Hard Candy Leman's Mint Hard Candy are delicious, individually wrapped mints with thin red and green stripes. Sometimes referred to as "church mints", these candies are a classic... -
Good and Plenty
$6.35Good and Plenty Made with only the finest ingredients, Good & Plenty is a sweet, chewy treat everyone can enjoy. It's made with real licorice extract, giving it a unique, flavorful taste. And with... -
Mini Sugar Daddy Candy Bulk
$6.95Mini Sugar Daddy Candy Bulk Mini Sugar Daddy Candy Bulk is America's oldest and most popular caramel lollipop. Made in the USA, it offers a delicious caramel treat that will satisfy your sweet tooth... -
Big Bol Candy
$6.35Big Bol Candy Get ready for a jaw-dropping adventure with Super Big Bol Candy! It's not just gum — it's a chew-tastic experience that takes your taste buds on a wild ride. This isn't your average... -
Gustaf's Fruit Pastilles Candy
$8.15Gustaf's Fruit Pastilles CandyGustaf's Fruit Pastilles Candy are chewy sugar-coated candies made in the UK and are the original English pastilles. Each pack contains a variety of flavors, including... -
Chick O Stick
$7.65Chick O Stick Chick-O-Stick is the perfect nostalgic treat that takes you back to your childhood! Formerly known as "Chicken Bones" candy, this classic favorite has remained unchanged in both recipe... -
Claey's Hard Candy - Wild Cherry
$5.65Claey's Hard Candy - Wild Cherry Bright red in color, these sweet, sugar-sanded, hard candies have a long lasting cherry flavor. Made in the USA, Claey's Hard Candy - Wild Cherry is the perfect... -
Out of StockOut of StockJelly Belly Licorice Bridge Mix
$13.95Jelly Belly Licorice Bridge MixLooking for an assortment of black licorice candies to satisfy your sweet tooth? Look no further than Jelly Belly Licorice Bridge Mix! This delightful mix includes... -
Bazooka Original Bubble Gum
$8.55Bazooka Original Bubble GumBazooka Original Bubble Gum is the great American Bubble Gum! This classic bubble gum has been enjoyed for generations and is a favorite among old-fashioned candy lovers... -
Dubble Bubble Nostalgic Bubble Gum
$13.95Dubble Bubble Nostalgic Bubble GumDubble Bubble Nostalgic Bubble Gum is a delightful blast from the past. Each piece of this bubble gum comes with a comic, just like in the good old days. Experience... -
Candy Cigarettes
$9.65Candy CigarettesCandy cigarettes made by World Confections. Â These candy cigarettes aren't just any ordinary candy - they're a blast from the past! These old-fashioned candies are reminiscent of the... -
Mini Caramel Cow Tales
$9.95Mini Caramel Cow TalesMini Caramel Cow Tales are the perfect sweet treat from Goetze's Candy. Enjoy the soft cream center & caramel coating in every bite. Indulge in the creamy taste of caramel candy... -
Boston Fruit Slices Large 5 Pound Box
$27.95Boston Fruit Slices Large 5 Pound Box Boston Fruit Slices Large are classic soft and chewy sugar-sanded fruit slices that come in a delightful assortment of sweet fruity flavors. Each slice is... -
Claeys Hard Candy Drops Horehound 6oz Bag
$2.75Claeys Hard Candy Drops Horehound 6oz Bag Claeys Hard Candy Drops Horehound 6oz Bag is the perfect nostalgic treat for those looking for a semi-sweet candy that is both flavorful and soothing. Made... -
Sconza Boston Baked Beans Candy
$6.95Sconza Boston Baked Beans Candy Sconza Boston Baked Beans Candy is a delightful treat that combines the perfect balance of sweetness and saltiness. Each roasted peanut is coated in a crunchy candy...
All Old Fashioned Candy transports you to simpler, sweeter days, offering classic confections that evoke nostalgia and charm. Perfect for themed parties, vintage events, or simply reliving cherished childhood memories, these candies are beloved for their timeless flavors and traditional appeal. They're ideal for creating unique candy buffets, thoughtful retro party favors, or sharing stories across generations. Discover the enduring joy of Licorice Allsorts, with their distinctive shapes and chewy textures, or the satisfying snap and long-lasting flavor of classic Rock Candy sticks. Explore our collection and rediscover the sweet tastes of yesteryear!