- Product
- Qty in Cart
- Quantity
- Price
- Subtotal
-
Out of StockOut of StockCashew Brittle
$10.65Cashew BrittleCashew Brittle is a delicious candy treat that will satisfy your sweet tooth and leave you craving more. Made by Old Dominion Peanut, a trusted brand since 1913, this buttery toffee... -
Charms Squares Candy 20 Pack
$40.95Charms Squares Candy 20 Pack These square-shaped Charms Squares Candies are an absolute delight for anyone who loves fruity flavors. Each pack contains 10 pieces of hard candy, which are available in... -
Out of StockOut of StockChowards Mints Spearmint 24 Pack
$24.75Chowards Mints Spearmint 24 PackChowards Mints Spearmint 24 Pack Enjoy this unique nostalgic candy mint! They have a unique texture, square shape, and the Choward's name on each piece. Each pack... -
Out of StockOut of StockSugar Babies 1.7 oz 24 Pack
$52.85Sugar Babies 1.7 oz 24 PackBite-sized, chewy caramel candies coated in a sweet sugary shell are what you can expect from the Sugar Babies. Perfect for candy lovers of all ages, this nostalgic treat... -
Charleston Chew Chocolate 24 Piece
$51.75Charleston Chew Chocolate 24 PieceIndulge in the rich and creamy taste of Charleston Chew Chocolate. This retro candy has been satisfying sweet tooth cravings for decades. Each pack contains 24... -
Out of StockOut of StockPeppermint Ribbon Candy Box - 6 Count
$11.95Peppermint Ribbon Candy Box - 6 CountPeppermint Ribbon Candy Box - 6 CountSevigny's Peppermint Ribbon Candy Gift Box. Enjoy this delicious old fashioned Christmas candy, spun into thin delicate... -
Out of StockOut of StockSour Dots Candy Theater Boxes 12 Pack
$22.55Sour Dots Candy Theater Boxes 12 PackSour Dots Candy Theater Boxes 12 Pack - Classic old-fashioned candy with a sour twist. Delicious Sour Dots come in mouth puckering flavors like grape, orange,... -
Whatchamacallit Candy Bar 36 Pack
$86.25Whatchamacallit Candy Bar 36 Pack Get ready to embark on a flavor adventure like no other with a Whatchamacallit candy bar, where crispy rice, rich caramel, and a velvety chocolate coating collide in... -
Out of StockOut of StockGilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Candy Corn 80 Sticks
$32.25Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Candy Corn 80 Sticks Gilliam Sticks Candy Corn Great for Halloween parties, but who cares if it's not Halloween. You can enjoy a little Halloween candy all year... -
Reeds Peppermint Hard Candy Rolls 24 Pack
$41.95Reeds Peppermint Hard Candy Rolls 24 PackReeds Peppermint Hard Candy Rolls 24 Pack - Shop Reed’s Candy in bulk online. The perfect old-fashioned hard candy treat for everyday enjoyment. Enjoy the... -
Assorted Old Tyme Mini Clear Toy Candy 9oz
$12.95Assorted Old Tyme Mini Clear Toy Candy 9oz Step back in time with classic Christmas Barley Toy Candies by Melville Handmade. Expertly handcrafted using traditional candy-making methods, these... -
Out of StockOut of StockCoal Mine Bubble Gum Pouches 24 Pack
$37.65Coal Mine Bubble Gum Pouches 24 PackCoal Mine Bubble Gum Pouches 24 Pack - Perfect stocking stuffer this Christmas season. Order now for a fruity surprise! #OldFashioned. Order yours now! Coal Mine... -
Atkinson Vanilla Caramels
$9.95Atkinson Vanilla Caramels Handcrafted with care, Atkinson’s Vanilla Caramels deliver a buttery chew infused with the smooth, comforting flavor of rich vanilla. Lovingly made in the USA, these... -
BB Bats Assorted 80 Piece
$16.95BB Bats Assorted 80 Piece BB Bats Assorted 80 Piece. The legendary retro treat you loved growing up is officially back on the shelves—now proudly brought to you by Stichler Products! Experience the... -
Honey Bun Cow Tales 100 Piece with Tumbler
$48.45Honey Bun Cow Tales 100 Piece with TumblerThe latest flavor of Cow Tales - Honey Bun Cow Tales. A delicious combination of Caramel, Vanilla, and a hint of Honey and Cinnamon. Reminiscent of a warm,...
All Old Fashioned Candy transports you to simpler, sweeter days, offering classic confections that evoke nostalgia and charm. Perfect for themed parties, vintage events, or simply reliving cherished childhood memories, these candies are beloved for their timeless flavors and traditional appeal. They're ideal for creating unique candy buffets, thoughtful retro party favors, or sharing stories across generations. Discover the enduring joy of Licorice Allsorts, with their distinctive shapes and chewy textures, or the satisfying snap and long-lasting flavor of classic Rock Candy sticks. Explore our collection and rediscover the sweet tastes of yesteryear!