All Old Fashioned Candy

Filter By

Sort By:

  • Product
  • Qty in Cart
  • Quantity
  • Price
  • Subtotal
  • Creme Savers Orange & Creme Hard Candy, 24 rolls. Bright orange and creamy white swirled retro candy. Creme Savers Orange & Creme hard candy, 24 rolls. Orange, white swirled retro hard candy.

    Creme Savers Orange & Creme Hard Candy Rolls 24 Pack

    $36.65
    Creme Savers Orange & Creme Hard Candy Rolls 24 PackCreme Savers Orange & Creme Hard Candy Rolls 24 Pack are back! Remember the sweet taste of zesty oranges swirled in delicious cream? Taste the nostalgia in each piece of Orange Creme Saver...
  • Product image 24 rolls of pink strawberry and white cream Creme Savers hard candy. Retro old-fashioned bulk candy.

    Creme Savers Strawberry & Creme Hard Candy Rolls 24 Pack

    $36.65
    Creme Savers Strawberry & Creme Hard Candy Rolls 24 PackCreme Savers are back! Remember the sweet taste of fresh strawberries swirled in delicious cream? Taste the nostalgia in each piece of Strawberry Creme Saver perfection.Each order contains 24...
  • 145 green Laffy Taffy Sour Apple pieces. Juicy, tangy, bursting sour apple flavor. Fun, nostalgic candy.

    Laffy Taffy Sour Apple 145 Piece

    $24.75
    Laffy Taffy Sour Apple 145 Piece Laffy Taffy Sour Apple 145 Piece is an old time favorite candy that is sure to bring back nostalgic memories. These juicy, tangy, and bursting with sour apple flavor taffies are the perfect treat for anyone with a sweet...
  • Astro Pops 6 pack, original retro lollipops. Three vibrant layers: cherry red, passionfruit green, yellow pineapple flavors. 6 Astro Pops, original retro three-layered lollipops with red, green, & yellow cherry, passionfruit, pineapple flavors.

    Astro Pops 6 Pack

    $23.65
    Astro Pops 6 Pack Astro Pops 6 Pack. The Original Astro Pop is a true retro candy. First introduced in the 1960's, during the Space Race, the Astro Pop is a three-layered lollipop with cherry red, passionfruit green, and yellow pineapple flavors. And...
  • Box of 80 Gilliam Old Fashioned Clove striped hard candy sticks, individually wrapped.

    Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Clove 80 Sticks

    $28.95
    Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Clove 80 Sticks Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Clove 80 sticks. Retro candy sticks like you would find at an old fashioned penny candy store. Each beautifully striped hard candy stick is individually wrapped and 5...
  • Gilliam Old Fashioned Pina Colada hard candy, 80 bright yellow and white retro sticks.

    Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Pina Colada 80 Sticks

    $32.25
    Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Pina Colada 80 Sticks Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Pina Colada 80 sticks. Enjoy this timeless throwback piece of candy any time and anywhere. With its bright colors of yellow and white and its delicious...
  • Reeds Butterscotch hard candy rolls, 24-pack. 7 individually wrapped, golden butterscotch candies per roll.

    Reeds Butterscotch Candy Rolls 24 Pack

    $31.25
    Reeds Butterscotch Candy Rolls 24 PackReeds Butterscotch Candy Rolls 24 Pack Delicious Butterscotch flavored hard candy first introduced in the 1880s. Reed’s Candy is a true old fashioned favorite. Sweet Butterscotch hard candies, individually wrapped...
  • 12 Tootsie Pop Drop theater boxes, colorful hard candy with chewy chocolate Tootsie Roll centers. Tootsie Pop Drops 12-pack theater boxes. Assorted fruit-flavored hard candies, chocolate centers, approx. 24 per box.

    Tootsie Pop Drop Theater Box 12 Pack

    $24.75
    Tootsie Pop Drop Theater Box 12 Pack Enjoy the classic taste of Tootsie Pops without the stick! Tootsie Pop Drops deliver the same fruity, hard candy shell you love, filled with a chewy, chocolatey Tootsie Roll center. Perfect for snacking on the go,...
  • 80 sour apple old fashioned hard candy sticks, green and white striped, individually wrapped, 5 inches long.

    Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Sour Apple 80 Sticks

    $33.95
    Old Fashioned Hard Candy Sticks - Sour Apple 80 Piece Each beautifully striped piece of green and white, old fashioned hard candy stick is individually wrapped. This sour apple candy is easy to enjoy anywhere, anytime.  Great addition to candy...
  • Goetze's Honey Bun Caramel Creams, golden cinnamon swirled caramel candy, smooth white cream center. Approx 40 pieces. Goetze's Honey Bun Caramel Creams candy, golden glazed chewy caramel, white cream center, 40 pieces per pound.

    Goetze's Caramel Creams Honey Bun

    $9.65
    Goetze's Caramel Creams Honey Bun Take a trip to the bakery without leaving the candy aisle with Goetze’s Honey Bun Caramel Creams. This inspired flavor mashup takes the legendary "Bull’s-Eye" and infuses it with the warm, glazed goodness of...
  • Golden Bonbon Sour JuJu Nougat Candy, white, soft, chewy, fruity, tangy, approx. 45 pieces per pound. Sour Juju Nougat Candy, soft chewy white nougat with tangy fruity jujube bits, approx. 45 pieces per pound.

    Sour JuJu Nougat Candy

    $9.65
    Sour JuJu Nougat Candy Sour Juju Nougat Candy is a delightful treat that pairs the tangy zing of sour jujube candies with the soft, chewy texture of classic nougat. Each bite bursts with fruity jujube bits, perfectly balancing sour notes with the...
  • Dubble Bubble Big Bars, 24 pack. Pink 3oz classic bubblegum bars, 24 per box.

    Dubble Bubble Big Bars 24 Pack

    $47.95
    Dubble Bubble Big Bars 24 PackDubble Bubble Big Bars 24 Pack. Enjoy the Original 1928 Flavor and design. Each bar is 3oz. 24 Dubble Bubble Big Bars per box. Old Fashioned CandyNovelty CandyBubble GumConcession Stand CandyDubble Bubble
  • 24 yellow Sugar Daddy milk caramel pops, classic old-fashioned candy, rich caramel flavor.

    Sugar Daddy Candy 24 Piece

    $51.75
    Sugar Daddy Candy 24 PieceThe Sugar Daddy Candy 24 Piece is a delicious milk caramel pops that will take you back to sweet memories of the past. This classic retro candy is a must-have for any candy lover. Each box contains 24 pieces of the mouthwatering...
  • 80 Gilliam Old Fashioned Peaches & Cream striped hard candy sticks, individually wrapped, 5 inches long.

    Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Peaches & Cream 80 Sticks

    $32.25
    Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Peaches & Cream 80 Sticks Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Peaches & Cream 80 sticks. Retro candy sticks, as you would find at an old-fashioned penny candy store. Each beautifully striped Old Fashioned Hard...
  • Tub of 130 Long Boys coconut candy pieces, creamy caramel with white coconut flakes, individually wrapped. Long Boys 130 piece tub of individually wrapped creamy caramel coconut candy. Old fashioned, chewy, retro fun-size treats.

    Long Boys Tub - 130 Piece

    $26.85
    Long Boys Tub - 130 PieceLong Boys Tub - 130 Piece Coconut Candy. Creamy caramel infused with real coconut flakes. Long Boys are creamy caramel infused with real coconut flakes and individually wrapped. Long Boy fun-size pieces are .39oz each. 130 Long...
  • Total: items /

Adding your products to cart

View Cart Continue Shopping

All Old Fashioned Candy transports you to simpler, sweeter days, offering classic confections that evoke nostalgia and charm. Perfect for themed parties, vintage events, or simply reliving cherished childhood memories, these candies are beloved for their timeless flavors and traditional appeal. They're ideal for creating unique candy buffets, thoughtful retro party favors, or sharing stories across generations. Discover the enduring joy of Licorice Allsorts, with their distinctive shapes and chewy textures, or the satisfying snap and long-lasting flavor of classic Rock Candy sticks. Explore our collection and rediscover the sweet tastes of yesteryear!