- Product
- Qty in Cart
- Quantity
- Price
- Subtotal
-
Blue Laffy Taffy
$24.75Blue Laffy TaffyBlue Laffy Taffy: Bursting with Blue Raspberry flavor, each wrapper features a joke! 145 pieces per order, Made in the USA. Order Now!Blue Laffy Taffy Old time favorite Laffy Taffy is... -
Bonomo Turkish Taffy
$32.25Bonomo Turkish Taffy Bonomo Turkish Taffy - Smack it, crack it, and enjoy this nostalgic candy assortment. A perfect addition to your next retro candy bar. Looking to add a touch of nostalgia to your... -
Out of StockOut of StockMary Jane Candy Tub
$18.25Mary Jane Candy Tub Mary Jane Candy Tub Mary Jane Candy is back for your enjoyment! Molasses and Peanut Butter flavors will send your taste buds on a trip to the sugar farms of the American South... -
Black Shoestring Licorice Laces 2 Pounds
$15.95Black Shoestring Licorice Laces 2 Pounds Black Shoestring Licorice by Gerrit Verburg is a must-have for licorice lovers everywhere. Soft and chewy, these black shoestring licorice laces come in the... -
Candy Flip Phone 12 Piece
$22.55Candy Flip Phone 12 PieceCandy Flip Phone 12 Piece is quickly becoming a nostalgic favorite among candy lovers. This retro candy features a pretend cell phone with a lollipop that 'flips' in and out... -
Pop Rocks Cotton Candy 24 Pack
$24.95Pop Rocks Cotton Candy 24 Pack Pop Rocks Cotton Candy 24 Pack. Taste the Explosion with Cotton Candy Pop Rocks! Fun Fact: Pop Rocks were introduced in the 1970’s, selling 500 million packages in only... -
Pop Rocks Grape 24 Pack
$24.95Pop Rocks Grape 24 Pack Pop Rocks Grape 24 Pack - The mouth-watering popping original flavor of grape never gets old. Fun for parties, for pinatas, and much more. This pack of Pop Rocks Candy will... -
Boston Baked Beans Theater Box 12 Pack
$26.85Boston Baked Beans Theater Box 12 Pack Classic candy-coated peanuts. These "Original" Boston Baked Beans are an old-fashioned candy favorite, with a sweet crunchy candy shell. The peanut and candy... -
Charleston Chew Change Maker 96 Piece
$36.65Charleston Chew Change Maker 96 PieceCharleston Chew Change Maker 96 Piece. Vanilla flavored Charleston Chew Change Maker candy bars have a nougat under a delicious chocolate coating! 96 pieces per... -
Out of StockOut of StockGobstopper Theater Box 12 Pack
$24.75Gobstopper Theater Box 12 PackGobstopper Theater Box 12 Pack: Gobstoppers are classic movie theater candy! 12 Gobstopper Theater Boxes, each box weighing 5 ounces. Perfect for sharing with friends or... -
Pop Rocks Bubble Gum 24 Pack
$24.95Pop Rocks Bubble Gum 24 Pack Pop Rocks Bubble Gum 24 Pack is here to take your taste buds on a sensational journey! Bursting with flavor and fun, this product combines the classic Pop Rocks candy... -
Pop Rocks Tropical Punch 24 Pack
$24.95Pop Rocks Tropical Punch 24 Pack Pop Rocks Tropical Punch 24 Pack is the ultimate explosive candy sensation! With its Tropical Punch flavor, these Pop Rocks will take your taste buds on a wild and... -
Reeds Root Beer Candy Rolls 24 Pack
$31.95Reeds Root Beer Candy Rolls 24 Pack Reeds Root Beer Candy Rolls 24 Pack are old-fashioned creamy Root Beer flavored candies that are perfect for anyone seeking a nostalgic treat. First introduced in... -
Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Bubble Gum 80 Sticks
$27.95Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Bubble Gum 80 sticks Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Bubble Gum is a delightful treat that will take you back in time. This retro candy is reminiscent of the... -
Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Strawberry 80 Sticks
$32.25Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Strawberry 80 Sticks Looking for a taste of nostalgia? Look no further than Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Strawberry! These retro candy sticks will transport you... -
Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Tangerine 80 Sticks
$33.95Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Tangerine 80 Sticks Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Tangerine, 80 sticks, offers a taste of retro nostalgia. Enjoy 80 orange and white striped candy sticks that... -
Out of StockOut of StockChick O Stick 36 Piece
$16.95Chick O Stick 36 Piece Chick O Stick 36 Piece. The old Chicken Bones candy now has a new name, but the recipe remains the same. These crunchy peanut candies are sprinkled with toasted coconut and... -
Out of StockOut of StockEaster Gumdrops
$4.25Easter Gumdrops Easter Gumdrops are a classic seasonal treat, bursting with bright colors and delicious fruity flavors. Soft, chewy, and coated in a light sugar dusting, these festive gumdrops are... -
Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Birthday Cake 80 Sticks
$27.95Gilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Birthday Cake 80 SticksGilliam Stick Candy Old Fashioned Birthday Cake 80 sticks. Retro candy sticks like you would find at an old fashioned penny candy store. Each... -
Bonomo Turkish Taffy Vanilla 24 Piece
$31.25Bonomo Turkish Taffy Vanilla 24 Piece Bonomo Turkish Taffy Vanilla 24 Piece. Smack it, crack it, and enjoy this creamy vanilla taffy nostalgic candy. A perfect addition to your next retro candy bar...
All Old Fashioned Candy transports you to simpler, sweeter days, offering classic confections that evoke nostalgia and charm. Perfect for themed parties, vintage events, or simply reliving cherished childhood memories, these candies are beloved for their timeless flavors and traditional appeal. They're ideal for creating unique candy buffets, thoughtful retro party favors, or sharing stories across generations. Discover the enduring joy of Licorice Allsorts, with their distinctive shapes and chewy textures, or the satisfying snap and long-lasting flavor of classic Rock Candy sticks. Explore our collection and rediscover the sweet tastes of yesteryear!