All Old Fashioned Candy

Filter By

Sort By:

  • Product
  • Qty in Cart
  • Quantity
  • Price
  • Subtotal
  • Dad's Root Beer Barrels, brown 1-inch hard candies, approx 60 per pound, rich classic root beer flavor. Dad's Root Beer Barrels hard candy, small brown 1-inch barrel-shaped candies, approximately 60 per pound.

    Dad's Root Beer Barrels

    $5.25
    Dad's Root Beer Barrels Discover the charm of Dad's Root Beer Barrels, where the classic meets the contemporary in a symphony of root beer flavor that’s made it a favorite among candy enthusiasts and, of course, dads everywhere! Embrace the...
  • Mike and Ike Original chewy candy, 1 lb, 250 pieces. Assorted fruit flavors: pink, orange, red, yellow, green rainbow mix. Vibrant Mike and Ike Original chewy candy, 1 lb, approx 250 pieces. Pink, orange, red, yellow, green mix.

    Mike and Ike Original

    $6.95
    Mike and Ike Original Mike and Ike Original are perfect for snacking, serving at events, or satisfying your sweet craving. This candy, made by Just Born, Inc., has been delighting candy lovers since 1940 with its delicious assortment of fruit flavors,...
  • Classic Smarties candy rolls, vibrant rainbow-colored tablets, fruity orange and lemon flavors, approx 60 per pound. Classic Smarties candy rolls, a colorful rainbow mosaic of vibrant, tart, sweet fruit-flavored tablets. Approx 60 rolls.

    Smarties

    $4.85
    Smarties Indulge in the sweet nostalgia of classic Smarties. These iconic candies have been a cherished treat for generations, offering a burst of fruity goodness in every roll. Each Smarties roll is a colorful mosaic of vibrant candy tablets, each with...
  • Vibrant red Cherry, yellow Banana, green Sour Apple Laffy Taffy bulk. Chewy 3-inch pieces, approx. 53 per pound. Bulk Laffy Taffy, 53 pieces per pound. Tangy, chewy red cherry, yellow banana, green sour apple taffy.

    Laffy Taffy

    $6.35
    Laffy Taffy Laffy Taffy is a chewy, juicy, and tangy taffy treat that will bring back nostalgic memories of your childhood. With its vibrant flavors and fun packaging, Laffy Taffy is sure to brighten up any occasion. Whether you're hosting a birthday...
  • Approximately 60 golden-brown Bit O Honey chewy square candies with visible roasted almonds, old-fashioned. Golden Bit O Honey chewy candy, bite-sized square taffy with real honey & roasted almonds, approx. 60 pieces per pound.

    Bit-O-Honey

    $7.95
    Bit O Honey Bit-O-Honey is an old-fashioned candy that has been satisfying sweet cravings for over a century. Made with real honey, roasted almonds, and a chewy texture, this candy boasts a distinctive flavor that is both sweet and nutty. Made by...
  • Classic bottle-shaped Bottle Caps candies, colorful red cherry, purple grape, orange, brown cola, root beer soda flavors. Colorful Bottle Caps hard candies, classic soda pop flavors like cola, cherry, grape, orange, root beer. Approx. 365 pieces.

    Bottle Caps Candy

    $8.55
    Bottle Caps CandyBottle Caps candies will have you taking a walk down memory lane. Pus, they’re oh-so-sweet and fun to eat. These delicious hard candies come in all of your favorite soda pop flavors to capture the taste you know and love in a...
  • Small, rainbow-colored Nik-L-Nip Wax Bottle Candies, approximately 55 per pound, with fruit syrup inside. Small, rainbow-colored Nik-L-Nip Wax Bottles, cherry, orange, lemon, lime fruit syrup, approx 55 per pound, retro candy.

    Wax Bottle Candy

    $8.15
    Wax Bottle Candy Wax Bottles, also known as Nik-L-Nips (aka Nickel Nip), are the ultimate nostalgia-inducing treat. The Nik-L-Nip name comes from the original cost of a nickel (5¢) and the method of opening it, by biting, or nipping the top off. Wax...
  • Claey's vibrant yellow lemon drop hard candies, 75 per pound, with sanded sugar coating.

    Claey's Hard Candy - Lemon Drops

    $5.65
    Claey's Hard Candy - Lemon Drops Welcome to the world of Claey's Hard Candy - Lemon Drops, the most popular nostalgic candy that will bring back memories of the good old days. These refreshing lemon-flavored hard candies will delight your taste buds with...
  • Butterscotch hard candy, individually wrapped in iconic yellow wrappers, approximately 87 pieces per 1 pound bag, classic flavor. Butterscotch Hard Candy, yellow wrapped, 87 pieces per pound, classic old-fashioned flavor.
    Out of Stock
    Out of Stock

    Butterscotch Hard Candy

    $4.25
    Butterscotch Hard CandyButterscotch Hard Candy, a nostalgic treat for all candy lovers. These classic hard candies are wrapped in an iconic yellow wrapper, representing the timeless appeal of this beloved confection.The Butterscotch Hard Candy is perfect...
  • Assorted Jujyfruits chewy candy, 170 pieces per pound, red, orange, yellow, green, black, various fruit shapes. Jujyfruits chewy candy, assorted fruit and vegetable shapes. Red, orange, yellow, green, black pieces, approximately 170 per pound.

    Jujyfruits

    $9.65
    Jujyfruits Jujyfruits are the chewy candy treat that brings back memories of simpler times. Whether you're reliving the 1950s or introducing this nostalgic candy to a new generation, Jujyfruits are sure to be a hit. Indulge in the perfect blend of...
  • Mini York Peppermint Patties, silver foil wrapped, 1.5-inch dark chocolate & white peppermint candy, approx 40 per pound. Mini York Peppermint Patties, approx. 40 per pound, wrapped in silver foil, dark chocolate, white peppermint candy.

    Mini York Peppermint Patties

    $10.65
    Mini York Peppermint Patties Mini York Peppermint Patties are the perfect sweet and minty combination of peppermint and dark chocolate. This classic confection has been a favorite since its introduction in 1940. Each patty measures approximately 1.5...
  • Bright orange jelly candy slices, sour citrus flavor. Classic chewy orange-shaped candy, about 32 pieces per pound.

    Orange Slices

    $4.25
    Orange Slices Orange Slices are a classic jelly candy shaped like a slice of orange. Each piece has a deliciously sour orange citrus flavor that will make your taste buds tingle. If you love nostalgic candy, then these Orange Slices are a...
  • Smarties candy necklaces, individually wrapped, multicolored sweet beads on stretchy cords, bulk, retro, vegan, gluten-free. Smarties Candy Necklaces, individually wrapped, multi-colored candy beads, retro, gluten-free, vegan.

    Smarties Candy Necklaces Wrapped

    $11.75
    Smarties Candy Necklaces Wrapped A retro candy favorite!  Convenient and delicious, these necklaces are candy "beads" strung on a soft stretchy cord.  Each candy necklace is individually wrapped, making them great for party treats and perfect...
  • Old Fashioned Candy Mix by Candy Nation, 1 lb, 80 pieces, various colorful nostalgic candies. Old Fashioned Candy Mix, 1 lb bag, 80 assorted colorful candies, Mary Jane, Bit O Honey, Chick O Sticks, Banana Split Taffy.

    Old Fashioned Candy Mix

    $9.65
    Old Fashioned Candy MixThe Old Fashioned Candy Mix is a delightful assortment of nostalgic candies specially curated by Candy Nation. It brings together all of your favorite old fashioned treats in one convenient package. Perfect for candy lovers of all...
  • Sweet strawberry bon bons, old-fashioned hard candy, individually wrapped in red strawberry wrappers, approx 60 pieces per pound. Strawberry Bon Bons, individually wrapped with detailed strawberry wrappers, old-fashioned hard candy, approx 60 pieces per pound.

    Strawberry Bon Bons

    $5.35
    Strawberry Bon Bons Strawberry Bon Bons are a delicious old-fashioned candy that will take you back to the good old days. Each piece of this hard candy is bursting with a sweet strawberry flavor, making it irresistible to candy lovers of all ages. The...
  • Total: items /

Adding your products to cart

View Cart Continue Shopping

All Old Fashioned Candy transports you to simpler, sweeter days, offering classic confections that evoke nostalgia and charm. Perfect for themed parties, vintage events, or simply reliving cherished childhood memories, these candies are beloved for their timeless flavors and traditional appeal. They're ideal for creating unique candy buffets, thoughtful retro party favors, or sharing stories across generations. Discover the enduring joy of Licorice Allsorts, with their distinctive shapes and chewy textures, or the satisfying snap and long-lasting flavor of classic Rock Candy sticks. Explore our collection and rediscover the sweet tastes of yesteryear!